Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Here's what I'm gonna tell you. I did not speak to a single brand that is profitable on TikTok. Welcome to the E-Com Show Podcast. 0:13 [upbeat music] I am your host, Andrew Maff, owner and founder of BlueTuskr. 0:16 From groundbreaking industry updates to success stories and strategies, get to know the ins and outs of the ecommerce industry from top leaders in the space. Let's get into it. 0:25 Hello and welcome to another episode of the E-Com Show. As usual, I'm your host, Andrew Maff, and today I'm going to talk to you about something very interesting. 0:37 Uh, I'm gonna talk to you about the reality of TikTok in ecommerce. 0:41 So [clears throat] there's a reason I wanted to do this one, uh, because I had a, a theory for a while, but could really only base it off of, uh, what I've, what we've done internally, and then obviously what I've, what I've heard and read. 0:55 Um, but then, then I got some more information. So, uh, uh, as of recording of this, I'm fresh off of a ridiculous run of conferences. Uh, if you're familiar with them, I was at... 1:09 Uh, I left my house Wednesday to go to Brooklyn, New York for ASGTG on a Thursday, got home on Friday, flew out on Sunday to go to Las Vegas to be f- there for MDS's INSPIRE event on Monday, followed by PROSPER, which was Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, and then flew home from Vegas on Friday and basically more or less just 1:34 slept for the entire remaining weekend. Uh, it was exhausting. Um, but it was a, it was a good time. Uh, I got, uh, I got to speak at ASGTG, a little bit at INSPIRE, and then at, at PROSPER. 1:47 Um, and between those three conferences, uh, I think, I know we spoke to over, I think it was like five or 600 different people. I would say a good couple hundred, at least two to 300 brands. 2:05 Um, and then obviously a ton of other partners in the space. And, uh, during, um, even INSPIRE. So INSPIRE was where this, this light bulb kind of, kinda hit me. 2:16 [clears throat] Uh, we-- They had like this networking thing where you'd go like table to table and you'd talk to everyone about stuff. 2:24 And I ended up using it as an opportunity to basically just ask almost a very similar question in the short amount of time we had, uh, 'cause I was, I was curious if I was understanding what I was understanding about TikTok, and then it just became everyone I talked to, I got curious about. 2:39 So I'm gonna flash forward to obviously the point of this. Uh, here's what I'm gonna tell you. I did not speak to a single brand that is profitable on TikTok. 2:52 I also asked them if they knew anyone that was profitable on TikTok, and they also did not know anyone that was profitable on TikTok. 3:01 And now I'm gonna throw you for a loop at, uh, I'm not gonna say which event 'cause then it'll be a little bit more obvious, but at one of the events, um, [clears throat] 3:10 uh, an agency that is solely focused on TikTok came up to us and was talking to us for a little while, and I asked them point-blank, "Are any of your brands profitable on TikTok?" And they, 3:25 they responded with, "Define profitable." [chuckles] Which if I have to define profitability, like I don't need, I don't need your answer. Um, so yeah, very interesting. 3:37 However, that does not mean TikTok is not a great channel. I still think TikTok is an amazing channel and I wanna, I wanna confirm and, and reiterate some of this. So here's the thing. 3:50 Uh, TikTok has a very similar, if not an even worse problem that Amazon has, which is there is a lot-- It's easy to get on the platform and sell a product and put it in an influencer's or affiliate's hands and let them pump it out. 4:07 Um, and so what that causes is a lot of shitty products. Um, and even, even if they're not shitty, a lot of stuff from overseas that is extremely inexpensive, right? 4:20 So crazy low COGS that you basically can't compete with. So what ends up happening is relatively different... Same, same end problem of Amazon, but b- Amazon, right, their fees keep going up, CPCs keep going up. 4:37 You've got competition coming in that keeps their product price point down, so your margins just get crushed. You can't really increase your product price. 4:44 I mean you can, but it's gonna bite you in the ass and you're not gonna see as much volume, so you kinda play this like pricing velocity game. On TikTok, it's, uh, relatively similar. 4:54 You can make your price whatever the hell you want, but [clears throat] the issue becomes the competition on there of other products as well, right? So TikTok, while, uh, you know, there's a lot of, of 5:08 disagreement around age group, no one's gonna tell you that there's no one over 25 on that app. Like, that's not true. 5:15 It's just, it's not as frequently used from people of like millennials and older audiences especially, like the boomers barely use it, and the audience is still not as big as the actual, uh, audience, right? 5:31 Like most boomers and stuff, they're on, uh, Facebook. 5:35 Then you kinda get millennials that still heavily cater to Instagram, but also use TikTok here and there, and then you have the new generation that's just basically all on TikTok, right? 5:44 So when you break it down on a percentage basis and also base it on like time spent, it is still a younger audience. So because of that, um, you know, it's not the most affluent audience. 5:57 So I've always found that products under like 30, $40 tends to do okay But this is where it became very interesting. So I met, uh, with a ton of brands. 6:11 Obviously, we work with a bunch of brands, and it's a very similar thing, and that's kind of what we're aiming for, of just, like, a break even on TikTok. And I wanted to make sure that, um... because I'd had some 6:22 conversations with a few of the brands that we work with, as well as a bunch of prospects that have just different ideas around how everyone thinks that there's just great profitability on Amaz- on TikTok. 6:33 So I even spoke to, especially at MDS, because it's a much... the Inspire event, it's a much, uh, uh, higher caliber group. Everyone there is doing, you know, at least several million dollars a year at a minimum. 6:47 Most are doing way more than that. And I met, I wanna say, 10, 12-ish brands that were doing well into six figures a month on TikTok. Like, 7:03 not, not small numbers. Not profitable. And they were okay with that, right? So here's, here's the reality, and here's what happens, right? So let's, let's take your average lower price point product. 7:16 So we're gonna, we're gonna say it's, uh, let's... I'm always bad at doing math on the fly, but we're gonna do $50. So it's already a little bit of a higher price point. We're gonna say it's 50 bucks. Um, you have to... 7:29 To get a good influencer to act as an affiliate for you on TikTok to push that product, you pretty much have to give them a good percentage. 7:41 Otherwise, they're just gonna go to other products that they can get a better percentage for, right? So usually, you're gonna have to be 20% or higher. 7:51 Um, the average is, like, 15%, but you want someone good, you're gonna have to get in that 20, 25% plus range. So let's call it 20%. So we're already giving up $10 of our $50 product. So we're gonna say, uh, COGS at 30%. 8:07 Oh man, this is where my math always goes horrible. What is that? We'll call it a little over $15, right? So now we're 25-plus dollars out, so 50% of our product's already gone, more or less, um, at least. 8:22 Then you gotta factor in, uh, fulfillment, right? So a lot of... 8:29 If, if you're Amazon only, a lot of people think, "Oh, the next best thing to do is just go to TikTok because they have a store, and Amazon will fulfill it." So you're using MCF. 8:38 Um, so then the problem there is MCF's not cheap. Uh, if your product's under, like, $30, I think, then it's, like, almost not feasible. Um, so now you're cutting into that. I cannot remember what their costs are. 8:52 So obviously you're way more than 50%. You know, you're probably in, like, the 60, 70% of your COGS, of your costs. 8:59 And so then you gotta factor in, uh, once you find things that are actually doing well, you're gonna have to run some ads. 9:05 So then you're factoring your advertising spend, and then if you wanna do it at scale and do TikTok correctly, right, you are... To, to do TikTok correctly, it's not, it's not hard. It's just a lot, right? 9:19 So you have to be posting at, on your own profile at a minimum a daily basis. Like, some do two, three times a day. And so that's a, that's a shit ton of content. That's a ridiculous amount of content, right? 9:33 'Cause we were used to, like, Instagram, where, like, you know, if you did once a day, you were pretty much, like, you were good. So a ton of content. 9:41 Uh, so then you gotta factor in all of the, uh, content creators you gotta work with, right? So different UGC creators just so you have your own content to post. 9:50 Then you gotta think about, uh, obviously your influencers, and you're sending them product. So you gotta get them product. Then you gotta think about, uh, you're gonna need to run ads. 10:03 So you'll be running some ads, 'cause you probably wanna stay on top, or you at least wanna retarget people. So now you've... 10:08 And then obviously, unless you have the large bandwidth to do that internally, which tends to be you need someone who's good with influencers and UGC creators, because it's pretty much relationship building. 10:19 You need someone who understands the algorithm, so that's usually a different social media person. Then you need a social ads person to run the advertising side. Usually those are different people. 10:28 For us, those are different people. They all have very different skill sets, and we try to specialize in certain things. Is your e-commerce business experiencing falling revenue? 10:36 BlueTuskr has helped many brands like yours excel. Unlike other marketing partners, BlueTuskr leverages a team of specialists to ensure every strategy is created and executed toward your business growth. 10:47 As an extension of your marketing team, BlueTuskr prides itself on helping to fill in the gaps and develop strong omni-channel strategies to diversify your business from the rest. 10:56 Ready to scale your marketing initiatives? Visit their website, bluetuskr.com. That's B-L-U-E-T-U-S-K-R dot com. Your overhead of people, or if you're paying an agency, now you're factoring in a management fee. 11:12 So think of all those fees, right? Uh, agency management fee or internal team management fee or contractors, whichever route you go. A-advertising. Uh, paying UGC creators so that you have your own, uh, your own content. 11:28 Um, if some of... If, if you go the influencer route, where they're not really affiliates, you're paying them too, but I didn't even factor that in. 11:35 But then you've gotta factor in fulfillment fees, COGS, good chunk of, uh, paying affiliates, and on top of it, affiliates usually find that they tend to do better when you have it on a discount. 11:49 So a lot of affiliates will get a 15, 20, 25% cut, and they want you to put it on TikTok Shop for, like, 15, 20, 25% off. So you're basically... You have to do an obscene amount of volume to break even. 12:07 And if you're doing low numbers, it doesn't make any sense. And it's really difficult It's not impossible, but it's pretty difficult to, like, dip your toe in TikTok because you can't, like-- 12:19 People do their due diligence. 2020 is when, uh, I know, big for the world in terms of pandemic, but I think it was massive for e-commerce. 12:29 Obviously, e-commerce took off and, you know, everyone did great and blah, blah, blah. But there was one thing that a lot of people don't talk about. 2020 brought out a lot of scammers. It was a lot of crap. 12:40 There was people pushing, you know, um, uh, uh, antibacterial stuff, masks. They were pushing all this stuff. Things would, like-- They-- Some people got really good. 12:51 They'd publish, like, great websites, and then you'd find out it was a scam. Like, people were getting screwed left and right. And so the average consumer, in my eyes, jumped forward in terms of online shopping by, like, 13:05 I don't know, five, ten years. Like, they started doing their own due diligence. 13:08 So if they came across an ad for something, they would go to, if-- especially if it was social media, they would go to the profile to see, like, who is this? Are they posting? Are they-- Are people liking them? 13:20 Do they have enough followers where it shows that they've been around? Then they're gonna Google you. Then they might go to Amazon. So-- Or they'll try to find your website or both, right? 13:29 So they're-- they got used to doing their own due diligence, and so that's how they shop now, which is why we tend to lean in more heavily in these omni-channel strategies. So with TikTok, it's no different. 13:39 So if you're doing all of this influencer stuff, you're doing, uh, affiliate, pushing them in TikTok shop, whatever, they're still gonna check out your TikTok profile. So you can't not do your TikTok profile. 13:51 You don't have to do multiple posts a day. You also don't necessarily have to do them every day. And again, I'm talking about if you wanna half-ass this thing and just dip your toe in. 14:00 And you could send it out to a handful of affiliates and just kinda see what happens. 14:04 But it's definitely not justifiable to pay an agency or anyone internally to do that at the rate that you need it to do-- need to do it for you to just kinda test that market. 14:14 So nine times out of ten, when someone comes to us, I usually tell them, "If you haven't tried TikTok yet, it's usually not best for an agency to get involved," because the value that they can bring i-at, at a low scale when a brand just wants to, like, try it out and not, like, really commit to it, most of the time it doesn't work. 14:38 So that's, that's where that becomes kind of interesting, right? And that's, that's also why, like, I'm gonna toot our own horn for a little s-- for a quick second here 'cause it's my podcast, so I'm gonna. 14:48 Um, th-one of the things that I love about us being full service is we are not biased to any individual marketing strategy. 14:56 So if you ask a TikTok agency what they think about TikTok, and if you think they can be successful, and the cost, and is it justifiable, and blah, blah, you bet your ass they're gonna say yes it is. 15:06 You ask an Amazon ads agency if you should be running Amazon ads when you have a wildly differentiated product that no one knows exists, and really all they're doing is benefiting off your brand search. 15:15 Are they gonna tell you to run Amazon ads? Of course. So we get to look at it in a little bit of a non-biased perspective and go like, "Look, we don't have to work with you in this route or in this route. 15:25 We've got 500 other things we could look at." So with TikTok, that's one of my favorite things to talk about is like, you're-- Of course a TikTok agency is gonna tell you that. 15:34 I think a TikTok-only agency is sometimes absolutely ridiculous 'cause they're not factoring in other things, but again, I digress. Um, so that's where it becomes kind of interesting. 15:44 But here's, uh, here's something I wanna make sure I, I clarify. I don't think TikTok's a bad channel. I think it's a great channel. I think that a lot of brands should absolutely do it. So 15:54 I think that here's the biggest problem, and because most of, of, of a lot of people that I end up having conversations with are in the Amazon space, right? 16:02 Uh, they're either solely a brand, uh, on Amazon, or they have, like, a little bit of a D2C presence. 16:11 And the biggest mistake that I see Amazon sellers make is they have this tendency to look at, uh, either an ACoS or a TACoS, right? That's all Amazon sellers care about. 16:22 And what it is is how much did I spend and how much did I get? In the D2C world, that de-depending on your product, that is usually not what you wanna look at. 16:32 What you actually wanna look at is your customer acquisition cost and your LTV. So you want your, your CAC to LTV ratio to be pretty damn nice, right? 16:39 Because in Amazon, the problem is you don't own the customer, so you have to pay for that f- [chuckles] you pay for that damn customer every single time, right? 16:47 So if they buy something from you on Amazon and you want them to come back and they didn't subscribe, they're gonna have to search for you again, and your competition, th- even if they know your brand, they-- your competition's gonna be bidding on your brand name, so you gotta pay to make sure they click on your brand, and so you gotta pay for them again. 17:02 So you are always factoring in cost per click in terms of your actual single purchase, even if you have a consumable. That's the reality. D2C, that's not the case, right? 17:14 You have-- You own the customer, so you can stay in front of them through social media and just kinda keep brand awareness so they don't forget who you are. 17:22 Or obviously, the main thing is, is your retention marketing, so ideally your email SMS is in a good spot so that you don't have to pay for that customer again. 17:31 So when you start looking at CAC versus LTV, you actually evaluate how much did I-- The real number you wanna know is how much is it costing me to acquire a new customer, and then how much does that cust- that customer spend with me over the course of the lifetime of, of them shopping with me? 17:48 And you have to define lifetime. 17:49 Typically, I look at a year because that's just how I run our business is like after a y- if I'm, I'm-- I don't do a ton investment into stuff that I won't see the benefit from for over a year. 17:59 A little bit, but not a lot, just because that's how I operate. So you'd have to evaluate what your LTV is, but let's say, let's say you're a supplement company, right? 18:08 So you're a supplement company, and you know if I acquire a new customer, they're gonna come back, and they're going to stay on this supplement on average for six months, right? 18:17 So if you can a- get them on a subscription, obviously that's fantastic, and plus your margins are better D2C, or if you can have them, uh, continuously repurchase because you're staying on top of them from an email perspective. 18:29 Who cares if you lose money on that first purchase? It's completely irrelevant because you're getting five more after that if they order every month. You're getting five more after that that you paid nothing for. 18:40 So you're looking at, okay, I spent, you know, five dollars to sell this twenty dollar bottle of supplements. Who cares? 18:48 Because the reality is you're actually gonna get, what, a hundred and twenty dollars for that five dollar purchase. It's just gonna be amortized over six months. 18:57 So that's the big difference that most brands don't look at when they come directly from Amazon 'cause they're not used to owning customer data, and that's fine. 19:05 But that's what you have to do from a D2C perspective if you wanna scale at a fast enough rate to actually start to see the fruits of your labor of everything that you're doing. 19:15 So where TikTok comes in, and the thing that I love about this channel, is I really like to look at Amazon as a customer acquisition channel. What can I do to acquire a customer who didn't know that I existed? 19:29 Because it's basically a large search engine, so they search for my-- a product that they didn't commit to a brand on. They found my brand. They purchased the product. What can I do to get them back to my website? 19:40 And what I'm doing is that's a very middle-of-funnel platform. They knew what they were looking for, and so they lo-- they were searching for it. 19:46 It's just right place, right time, and as long as everything's aligned with my marketing on Amazon, I will acquire that customer. Then I have to do what I can to get them to come back to my website. TikTok is different. 19:56 It's a lot more top-of-funnel, but it's still a fantastic customer acquisition channel because you can educate a lot better. 20:04 The biggest problem with Amazon, the thing that drives me crazy, is if you have a wildly differentiated product or if you have, um, elements of your product that are clearly differentiated from your competition, right? 20:18 So if it's something that, uh, people already know exists, there's act-- there's search volume for it, so they're gonna search for it, and they're gonna come across it. 20:25 But the problem is you do not get that sale until you pay for that click. 20:30 So they clicked, and they come to your listing, and as long as your listing is completely optimized and they're educated, then maybe they'll convert. TikTok, you're paying nothing comparatively, right? 20:42 So you don't actually pay until they, they... Well, you do a little bit. So you pay for, like, a view-through-ish, but they don't act- you don't actually pay until they click for the most part, right? 20:52 The, the cost for a view, like, even on Facebook, like, you can-- When you do meta ads, I mean, you could get view-through, uh, costs down to, like, a th- like less than a penny. So who cares? 21:04 Um, TikTok is very similar, so you can educate them for wildly inexpensive before they click, and then so once they've clicked, they're now educated. The problem is, is that it's, it's not profitable. 21:15 So you can actually get in front of people that may not know your product exists, or you can get in front of, in front of people that it-- you need to further explain why you're better than your competition. 21:27 So TikTok's an amazing top-of-funnel customer acquisition channel. Amazon's an amazing middle-of-funnel customer acquisition channel. 21:36 But if you wanna-- I, I don't suggest breaking even on Amazon 'cause it's, it's a bit of more of a slog. But on TikTok, if you can break even, the best part about TikTok, hands down, is you get to keep the data. 21:48 Amazon doesn't let you do that. 21:49 So with TikTok, if you can break even to acquire a new customer and you have a product that either you can cross-sell, upsell, or get them to repeat purchase, then all of a sudden, your customer acquisition cost is effectively flat. 22:04 So you give up the first product, and you know that they're gonna come back and purchase three, four, or five more times. Who cares if you break even on TikTok? I would do that at a ridiculous volume too. 22:14 So for the brands that I spoke to that were doing six figures a month and just absolutely crushing it on TikTok and breaking even, most people looked at them like they were crazy. 22:23 I looked at them like they're fucking geniuses because I immediately went like, "That's, that's so smart for a product that you can get repeat purchases on." Because you can get ahead of getting really good affiliates. 22:34 You can offer every-- like the best ones some good cash, and they can make some decent money off of it. They can do a ton of volume, and you can acquire new customers who you needed to educate in that type of way, right? 22:47 When they go to Amazon, they've already been educated on the product line in one way or way, one way or another. 22:53 But if you're, like, kinda different from your competition, they're not gonna know until they click on the listing. 22:58 If you're a completely different product where it's, like, a new category, you're, you're screwed because they don't-- there's no search volume for that type of stuff. 23:04 So you have to educate more top-of-funnel, and that's where TikTok is amazing. Thank you. [clears throat] That was my rant. And I, as you can tell, I always get super heated on some of these things. 23:15 But yeah, the re-- Look, I'm not... Here, here's the other thing. I'm gonna get comments. I'm gonna get emails. I'm gonna get people messaging me on T- on LinkedIn. 23:22 It's gonna be so many that are like, "I'm profitable on TikTok," blah, blah. I'm not saying it's physically impossible. I'm sure there's someone out there that's doing it. But what I will say, 23:33 business owners, especially e-commerce owners, have a, uh, the shiny object syndrome, right? Where you, you wanna do the next thing because you heard so-and-so's doing really well. 23:43 Well, they're gonna tell you about their revenue because it's a very fancy vanity metric, but the reality is, what are they actually profiting from that? 23:50 And sometimes you have to dig into that because they may tell you what they're profiting factoring in their CAC versus LTV ratio, not on that first purchase. That's where those things get kinda interesting. 24:00 But the reality is most brands, not all, but most brands are using TikTok as a customer acquisition channel, but they are breaking even, and they are not profitable on that channel, and that's okay. 24:15 Thank you for coming to my weekly rant. As usual, I appreciate you all joining me. Please do the whole normal thing. 24:21 Rate, review, subscribe, all that fun stuff on whichever podcast platform you prefer, or head over to the ecommshow.com to check out all of our previous episodes. 24:27 But as usual, thank you all for joining me, and I'll see you all next time. Have a good one. [upbeat music] Thank you for tuning in to The E-Comm Show. 24:36 Head over to ecommshow.com to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform or on the BlueTuskr YouTube channel. 24:44 The E-Comm Show is brought to you by BlueTuskr, a full-service digital marketing company specifically for e-commerce sellers looking to accelerate their growth. Go to bluetuskr.com now for more information. 24:57 Make sure to tune in next week for another amazing episode of The E-Comm Show. [upbeat music]