Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] I think what's most important is having a kickass product. Most of the people who sign up say that they heard about us from a friend or family. 0:18 And I want a good show, damn it. You ready for a good show? Doing awesome. Yeah. [laughs] Excited to talk to you, Andrew. Thanks for having me on. Yes. To build their stand. 0:35 I've always been doing something- I was looking into archery, and my dad said, "Hey, do you guys wanna start an archery store?" Which is very nerve-wracking because that's how I learned this business. 0:42 I mean, yes, of course, like we need to get- Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of The E-Comm Show. 1:07 I'm your host as usual, Andrew Maff. And today, I am joined by the amazing Mike Salguero, who is the founder and CEO of ButcherBox. Mike, how you doing? You ready for a good show here? Yeah. Doing great. 1:18 Thanks for having me. Yeah. I appreciate you being on the show. So I always like to start off in a relatively traditional manner, but I'd like to hear it... 1:25 I know at this point, you've been on enough podcasts and had your face everywhere that everyone already kinda knows who you are. But how would you explain what ButcherBox is to, in layman's terms? 1:37 I mean, having my face everywhere is, uh... takes some getting used to. [laughs] So, um, ButcherBox- Here to help... uh, we ship meat in the mail, uh, meat raised better, um, in the mail directly to customers. 1:52 Uh, we have hundreds of thousands of subscribers, and we compete against the butcher. 1:58 We want you to stop going to the grocery store and wondering what you should be purchasing or who treated animals well or who treats the environment well, and purchase from us. Um- Easy enough... 2:09 we started with, uh, grass-fed beef, uh, pasture-raised grass-fed beef, and, uh, moved into, um, pasture-raised chicken, organic free-range chicken, uh, pasture-raised pork, et cetera, et cetera, and have 2:25 120 different products. Uh, we're t- really trying to meet the customer in all of their needs in the kitchen. 2:31 Everything from, uh, you know, um, a steak that needs to be cooked, um, from raw to pre-cooked items that can just be opened up and microwaved and, uh, served quickly. Beautiful. How did you come up with this? 2:46 Because your background, not necessarily in, in the meat realm. No, no. So how, uh, how did you-- how did this come to be? Yeah, um, well, I was running a company before this. 2:58 Um, so I, I, I got out of college, um, and I decided that I wanted to, um, do something entrepreneurial. And, and in college, I was trying some entrepreneurial hustles. Uh, I started at, in real estate. 3:11 I rented apartments. Um, that's where I met my wife and my first co-founder. 3:16 Then I decided I wanted to get a real job, so I went on literally 75 informational interviews and finally landed a job at a real estate developer. I did that for three years. I didn't like that. 3:28 That was my only, like, real job, and I, I, I really regret that I did that. Um, got my MBA at night at Babson, which was like the entrepreneurship school, and then started my first company, which I ran for eight years. 3:39 We raised $30 million of financing. It was called custommade.com, and, um, ended up hitting a wall, losing everyone's money, shutting down. Uh, I took the weekend off, and then I started ButcherBox. Um- That's it... 3:52 and I've been running ButcherBox for, uh, eight and a half years, roughly. So I've been CEO-ing for 16, 17 years at this point, um, uh, with [chuckles] really no time off other than, you know, vacations and whatnot. 4:06 Um, I got into ButcherBox because, uh, when I left CustomMade, I decided that I didn't wanna raise money, and I wanted to follow, uh- [laughs]... 4:14 Tim Ferriss' "4-Hour Workweek" and find something that was gonna be a side hustle, uh, that was not gonna take all of my time and, uh, that I could literally check my numbers from a cafe in Argentina and then go about my day. 4:29 I was looking to have 1,000 subscribers, um, who I was looking to make $20 a month off of and thought with 20 grand I could, uh, pay a couple of customer service people and, um, you know, have like a little, nice little hobby business. 4:44 I was particularly interested in grass-fed beef and, uh, animals raised better. I had read, uh, Michael Pollan's book, "The Omnivore's Dilemma," um, and my wife, uh, and I were trying to clean up our diets. 4:56 Um, she has an autoimmune thing, and we were trying to, uh, eat better. 5:01 And a lot of these diets, like an elimination diet, where you eliminate gluten and dairy and soy and nightshades from your diet, and then you add them back in, a lot of those diets said eat grass-fed beef. 5:11 And, um, I lived in downtown Boston. I just got really interested in, like, where do you buy grass-fed beef? And couldn't find any, so ended up buying it from a farmer, and then, like, 5:22 I bought too much, so then I was selling it to my friends. And one of my friends was like, "This would be so much better if it was delivered to my house." [laughs] And I was like, "Yeah, that would be better." 5:33 Um, and so I started trying to figure out how to make that happen. And this is, like, while CustomMade was kind of falling apart. 5:39 Um, uh, I was, you know, in the background trying to figure out, like, how would you ship meat in the mail and whatnot. Um, and I, I, I, I hit multiple roadblocks. 5:52 Um, uh, but, you know, doors opened and things happened and, uh, started with a Kickstarter in 2015. Uh, went really well and, um, have been kind of, you know, holding onto the tiger's tail since then. That's awesome. 6:08 The... There's so many things that you have been successful with through ButcherBox that so many other companies have failed in, and that's more or less what I imagine we're gonna talk a lot about today. Great. 6:20 One of the, one of the very first things I gotta ask, uh, you obviously had some, some downfalls [chuckles] with venture capitalists. I don't blame you. Mm-hmm. 6:28 So you are now basically, you know, far into nine-figure company, and you have bootstrapped- Yep... the entire thing. Yep. 6:37 When you talk to companies that bootstrap and they hit like, you know, they start breaking seven figures, they hit a wall, and they don't know what to do, and they kinda get stuck, and then they start looking for investments or loans- Yep... 6:48 and it, it kinda gets ugly. Yep. How, how on earth did you bootstrap ButcherBox? Yeah. So, um, uh, the, the place where people get stuck when they bootstrap is inventory. Yeah. Far and away, that is the problem. 7:07 So the problem is you grow and you're like, "Ooh, we're growing. We need to, like, invest in inventory ahead of our growth." 7:12 And then you end up with a bunch of inventory, which is cash on a shelf, unless you figure out how to finance it, and then people are like, "Oh, I need money." 7:19 And I have lots of people who ask me for bootstrapping advice, and I see so many examples of people falling into that trap. 7:26 Now, the, the trick is that you need to figure out how you're gonna finance your inventory and not own your inventory yourself, and there's a couple ways to do that. You can get debt. 7:39 You can ask your inventory providers to do it for you. So in our case, we had, um, people who were cutting our meat who were, one, they gave us 30-day terms, and two, they were actually really bad at invoicing us. 7:52 So early on- [laughs]... it would take, like, a month for them to invoice us, and then we had another 30 days, so it was like 60 days afloat. And we built our entire model- [laughs]... around wanting to be bootstrapped. 8:02 So, um, for example, we had this curated box. This is what we started with. We had you chose beef, beef and chicken, or beef, chicken, and pork, and we were gonna send you whatever we wanted to. Why did we do that? 8:15 Everyone's like, "Uh, nobody buys meat that way. Why... Who, who's gonna buy meat that way?" 8:18 And we're like, "Well, you know, like Blue Apron and all those companies seem to just, like, send you whatever meals they want, so w- I, I think there's a market." 8:26 The reason why we did that is because I didn't want inventory sitting on a shelf. The minute I'm trying to guess at how many ribeyes are gonna... 8:31 I'm gonna sell this week is the minute that I have a bunch of inventory sitting on shelf. Yeah. 8:36 Um, we did find very advantageous terms with our, um, our meat providers, where we're like, "Hey, you need to put up inventory..." And we still do this today. 8:47 They have, like, weeks of inventory on-hand in their facility, and they don't charge us for it until they ship it to our distribution center. 8:55 We also have a line on our distribution center where the distribution center owns the inventory, or it's owned by a third party, but the distribution center is the person who's, like, responsible for it. 9:03 [smacks lips] So the way it actually works is I buy a piece of meat, it gets cut, it gets put in the distribution center. Um, customer pays for it. [clears throat] We ship it out. 9:14 Once it's shipped out, I have seven-day terms to repurchase that inventory, or to, sorry, to buy that inventory. That is what's called, like, a, um, what is it? A positive cash conversion cycle, right? 9:25 So, like, we, we get p- Yeah... we get paid by our customers before the inventory leaves the facility. We have not paid anything on inventory. 9:35 And the beauty of that is it puts our, like, incentives and the company's incentives in alignment. 'Cause where you get into trouble is where you're like, "Oh, we can't grow anymore 'cause I can't afford the inventory." 9:45 And then what people do, what I see countless errors on this, is, uh, especially people who aspire to bootstrap or whatever, um, y- you're trying to solve a debt problem with equity dollars. Mm-hmm. 9:59 Meaning, like, inventory is a debt problem. It's like you get a loan, you, you, you use your inventory. Exactly. You get more inventory. That's generally fixed with debt. 10:11 What I see a lot of founders do is they, like, go and raise $5 million to finance their inventory, and the problem with that is like, yeah, but if you grow, if you 10X the business, you're just gonna have to raise more money. 10:23 Yeah. So it's, it's really important to figure out early. I'm talking to a guy right now. He's, um, working in a... 10:29 Uh, I don't think it really matters, but, like, uh, he, he's working in a space, and he has his choice of, like, 10 different vendors, and he's like, "Well, like, these guys have the best quality, and what about these guys?" 10:38 And I was like, "Dude, the only thing that matters is terms. What terms are they giving you? How much inventory are they willing to put up? 10:43 How much inventory are they willing to put on their shelves, and what are the terms?" Like, everything else is, like, kind of, it, it, it doesn't matter nearly as much when you're starting out. How... 10:54 So [clears throat] when you're going to these vendors, you're talking to, you know, manufacturers or, you know, in your case, you're going all the way back to farmers and dealing with butchers, et cetera. 11:02 How are you having these conversations with them to actually do that? 'Cause I know it's not a very common practice. Most people that sell online are sticking with a ton of inventory. It's sitting on the shelf. 11:13 To your point, it's just cash sitting on a shelf. Yep. 11:15 How do you even, how do you even begin that conversation, and how do you make it beneficial for them to make sure that you're in a good position to keep scaling it out from there? Yeah. 11:26 Um, so f- first of all, I wanna say there's a whole bunch of stuff on the marketing side as well. 11:30 So if we wanna talk about bootstrapping and how to think about a marketing, I'm happy to talk about that as well- Oh, yeah... like later. 11:35 But on the supplier side, how do we, uh, go about talking to suppliers about, uh, like inventory and whatnot? So, uh, I a- oftentimes find that people don't know what train they're on. 11:51 It's like you're either on the venture capital train or you're on the bootstrapping train. You can't be on both trains at the same time. You'll, like, end up in the splits, and you'll, y- you just... It doesn't work. 12:01 You're gonna die. Yeah. So oftentimes you have bootstrap people who then wanna go behave like a venture, venture-backed company. In our case, we're like, "Look, w-we are not raising money. 12:13 So if you want to work with us, the only way that you can work with us is to give us 30-day terms. That's it. Like, that's what I'm looking for. That's what we need." 12:23 And, you know, I do want to say that, um, I had run a company before that was funded by Google and others. We had raised $30 million of financing, so, like, I had a name, a bit of a name for myself, right? 12:35 So I, I have to recognize that I came from a place of privilege. But I think that there are ways to do it for anybody. You just have to know that that's the train you're on, right? 12:44 I think oftentimes people are like, "Well, this is the only provider I could find." 12:49 And it's like, well, actually, if you, if you wanna go the route of not raising money and this is the only provider you can find, I would argue they're not a provider. 12:58 Like, you need to find someone different because- Yeah... this person is not going to be a provider for you. 13:04 That type of thinking is not necessarily-- Well, they-- Like, most people wanna be like, "Oh, I'm bootstrapping, I'm bootstrapping," but then like, "I'm gonna make these three decisions," which is gonna make it virtually impossible to bootstrap. 13:14 Um, it-- So if you're on the bootstrap train, you need to be on the bootstrap train, which is like, "I'm only working with you if you do this." Um, and that's a... 13:23 Yeah, that's, um, I think a, a, a, a change from how most people wanna operate. Yeah. So to your point, and my favorite subject, let's, let's look at the marketing side on how you did that, right? 13:34 So one thing, which you've already name-dropped one of them, I know probably more subscription brands that have failed than have actually succeeded. Yep. 13:42 So the marketing side of subscription brand, and obviously you've figured out the supply side, and ob- well, of course, you figured out the marketing side, but let's, let's hear about that. 13:50 I know that you did a lot behind influencer marketing, affiliate marketing, things like that, but what has been the main driver from a marketing perspective that has allowed the business to keep scaling? Yeah. 14:03 So, um, I guess a couple things. So first of all, again, we needed to be, um... We, we didn't raise any money. 14:10 So we needed to be what we called box one profitable, which means I need to make enough money on the first box that we ship to you so that, um, we can afford to find more people. 14:25 Uh, that is not how most companies work, right? Usually it's like- Yeah... 14:31 "It costs me $100 to acquire a customer, and we make 25, and, like, we think that they're gonna, like, pay us back over time, but we haven't been around in business long enough, but we're pretty hopeful." Mm-hmm. 14:43 And in a, in a non-subscription business, it's even more risky 'cause you're like, "We don't know what the re-purchase rate is." 14:49 At least in a subscription business, you could start looking at your churn rate and start, like, kind of inferring how long people are gonna stay. We didn't have that luxury. 14:57 We had to make money on the customer on the first box. Um, and so it was like, "Hey, we have a $20 profit. Uh, how are we gonna find a customer for $20?" And what we did was [clears throat] we, um... 15:13 First of all, we did Kickstarter, and we did Kickstarter because we thought that there was a way to arbitrage Kickstarter, uh, which we were right about. 15:22 Um, and then during the Kickstarter campaign, we noticed there was an influencer who, like, tweeted about us, and we saw a flurry of, like, signups, and we were like, "Okay, that'll work." 15:32 And at the time, this is 2015, um, Thrive Market, um, was out, and they had done this thing where they had, like, all of these people in the paleo space were saying, like, "Sign up for your Thrive Market subscription." 15:46 And we were like, "I wonder if they would sell grass-fed, like a, like this service, you know, meat raised better, but specifically grass-fed beef." Yeah. 15:56 And so, so we just ended up, um, finding anybody who had talked about grass-fed beef. Um, you know, like, "Hey," the, the same people that, like, m-my wife and I were following, right? 16:07 These bloggers who are like, "Eat grass-fed beef for a, for a, a month, and then, like, you know, intro- reintroduce stuff." 16:13 We're like, "Hey, I started this company 'cause I was following your blog, and it said to eat grass-fed beef, but I didn't know where to get it, so I started this company. 16:21 And, uh, do you wanna tell your audience about it? And, um, by the way, we can't pay you upfront. The only way that we can pay you is on residual." And so we signed up people to basically 16:34 no payment upfront, but a, you know, $15 per subscriber per month- Commission... type of bounty. Yeah. And, you know, one thing is, I'm prefacing this, this was 2016, that arbitrage has largely gone away. 16:49 Like, I don't think that there, there aren't many people- Yeah... who are willing to do that anymore. The influencers that we worked with now, uh, are like, "Hey, we want money upfront." 16:59 Like, very few people are willing to take that risk anymore. Um, but there's always, like, there's always a hole in the internet. Like, the internet was built on arbitrage. 17:08 It was built on finding these pockets where there's a ton of value and is relatively cheap and exploiting those pockets. Um, and so, you know, I, I, I've said on podcasts before, 17:22 you really need, like, one trick to get yourself to, like, a 35 to a $50 million business. Um, we got... So our growth was we did 300 grand. 17:33 Uh, we started in September, did 300 grand, um, in that first part of that year. We did five million the second year, 35 million the third year, 105 million the next year. So that was, like, our growth curve. 17:45 We ran one trick up to 33 million. That one trick was the influencer strategy. And we went deeper and deeper and deeper and deeper and deeper into it, and I think that that's, like, you know, most, um... 17:57 I have an analogy of, like, you're wildcatting for oil and, and you wanna-- in marketing, you wanna have a very, like, cheap shovel, and you're just digging these small holes, and when you find oil, it's like, keep digging there. 18:09 Don't go further. Don't take your shovel to some other thing 'cause you're supposed to be like... You as a CEO are supposed to figure out all the different ways to advertise. Like, no, just focus on that hole. 18:18 And it's like, "Oh, wow, this is like a really deep well." Build more, get other people involved, big... Build infrastructure. Like suck that, suck that well dry before you move on. So we went from, 18:30 I mean, we were basically in business for almost three years before we ever did a single Facebook ad. Jesus. And then we did Facebook ads- [laughs]... because, um, which is a hilarious story. 18:41 Um, I have this like really funny video of my daughter screaming at my wife for bacon. She was like really mad there was no more bacon, and so she's like, "More bacon!" 18:51 [laughs] And it's, it's like annoying but like catchy. And, um, we, [laughs] we posted that just on our Facebook page, and people loved it, and we were like, "We should just advertise." 19:02 And so we just started advertising and it worked. It was like, "Get free bacon in your first box." And, 19:07 um, so yeah, I mean, you know, and, and now we, we advertise everywhere and we do everything possible, but, um- Yeah... starting out, it was like one, one trick. One trick. That's awesome. 19:18 So you more or less started off, uh, completely arbitraging the influencer side, uh, basically seeding them 'cause you didn't really pay them until they actually made a sale. That's right. 19:26 Now I know that you obviously just mentioned, but I've been looking through like your social and stuff like that. I saw you were just tweeting about, uh, or X-ing, if they should call it that now- Yeah... 19:35 of, uh, of actually, um, the advertising that you've been doing. I know J- January you're starting to see some better results with some of the advertising side of things. 19:42 Like what has been the approach from an advertising perspective? Are you still primarily focused on social media? Have you found kind of that other hole outside of the influencer side that you've been focused on? 19:54 You know, like, um, so subscription businesses are amazing in many ways because they compound on themselves. So- Yeah... you know, you sign up, uh, $100 worth of revenue in month one, hopefully more. 20:09 Let's call it $1,000 in revenue in month one. You churn out 10% of those people, so now you have $900 worth of revenue, and if you add another 1,000, now you have 1,900, and then you run that again, you've got... 20:22 So it, it just compounds on itself in a way that's like you can, you can grow really fast if you figure something out. Yeah. 20:29 Subscription businesses get really hard a little bit later when they are, uh, when your churn is eating your customer base. So when you're dealing in multiple hundred thousands of customers, 20:44 e- even if you, a-a- I always say, like even if you're sending people bricks of gold in the mail, at a certain point they're like, "Stop with the bricks of gold." Like everyone- [laughs]... 20:51 like y- your churn, you will have churn no matter what. Yeah. Uh, and so what ends up, what ends up happening is your churn, when your n- when your number of subscribers is so big, is a big number. 21:04 And so where we are right now is like we have hundreds of thousands of, of subscribers. 21:08 We have north of 400,000 subscribers, and, um, you know, on any given month, you've gotta replicate tens of thousands of people in order, [laughs] in order to like grow or it... really in order to tread water, 21:22 and that becomes really hard, right? So 'cause you're deepening your pools, there's less people. It's like it's a whole thing. Um, so I mean, we advertise everywhere. 21:33 Um, we are mostly in the demand space, so, um, you know, the Facebooks of the world and Instagrams- Mm-hmm... and, uh, TikTok and, uh, we've done a bunch of TV. 21:45 We've done a bunch of brand advertising, like top of the funnel stuff, awareness stuff. Um, and ultimately, like, you know, which I'm happy to talk about as well, because we're unfunded, we have a very long time horizon. 21:58 Like we don't need to sell. We don't need to grow at any sort of particular rate. We don't really wanna go public. We don't wanna sell the company right now. So 22:06 I, I, I think what's most important is having a kickass product. Like that's by far the most important. Like- Yeah. 100%... 22:14 most of the people who, who sign up say that they heard about us from a friend or family, and I think that that is going to continue to be the case. So it's like how do you activate that? 22:23 How do you like inspire people to share, et cetera, um, is a big piece of kind of the work that we do. Yeah. I, I've always said like marketing's actually kinda easy if you've got a great quality product- Right... 22:36 in place 'cause it's just about being in front of the right people at the right time and reminding them that you exist. So it does obviously make a lot of sense. 22:44 So, you know, the subscription side, you're compounding through that. 22:47 The, the advertising side, one of the questions that always comes up when you're focused on top of funnel things, you know, between whether you're doing it digitally or whether you're doing it through commercial, how are you 22:57 painting any kind of ROI when you're looking at... Like if we look back at your influencers, right? You wanted to make sure that you were basically just paying them 15 bucks a box. 23:06 How do you make sure that your top of funnel aspect is still tied to some direct ROI since it's not as, uh, tangible as you'd like it to be? You mean the brand, the brand spend? Like, like the- Yeah... 23:18 the real top, top, top, top of funnel? Correct. Yep. Uh, I don't have a good answer on that. I mean, we have, um... 23:25 W- I mean, my answer would be that we try to measure everything, and so we don't, we don't play in like the very, very top of funnel unmeasurable stuff. 23:34 We have, and we've frankly, I have not seen any economic value [laughs] from it. Um- Yeah... 23:40 and so, you know, it was like two years ago that we put like seven and a half or $8 million into brand spend, and at the time it was like, "What is brand spend?" 23:47 It's like, "Well, it w- we, we just won't put a conversion button on it, and then it's brand spend." It's like, that sounds like a bad idea. [laughs] No goal. Just name it. I'm not sure that's a good idea. 23:58 Uh, so I, I, I would say the thing, the brand spend that I think is really interesting for ButcherBox is, uh, enabling our customers to send boxes to their friends for free or like- Yeah... 24:13 giving them tools to talk about us and build that word of mouth 'cause, I mean, we've shipped a box to over 1.5 million households in this country. 24:22 It's a lot of people who have tried our product, which is like really cool and humbling and scary and all that. But like- [laughs]... uh, you know, there's, there's like- 24:30 Uh, ways to harness that that aren't like, "Oh, do a Super Bowl ad. That'll work." Um, I don't know how to do the Super Bowl ad and have it work. Uh, and frankly- [laughs]... I don't think we can afford it. 24:44 I think we need to, like, continue just chipping away at, like- Yeah... you know, the basics. Totally understand. Mike, I don't wanna take up too much more of your time. I know you're super busy. 24:54 I would love to give the opportunity here, let everyone know they can find out more about you, and of course, more about ButcherBox. Yeah. 25:01 Um, well, you can follow me on Twitter at, @MikeSalguero, S-A-L-G-U-E-R-O, um, where I try to tweet, um, which is a whole thing and hard. Uh, and you can go to butcherbox.com. 25:15 Um, uh, we have a promo code Mike sent me, um, if you want that. I think it's, like, 20 or $30 off your first box. And, uh, yeah, I mean, I, um, I think that... 25:30 I, I think operating a company in general is a very lonely endeavor. Um, and I, uh, oftentimes encourage people to find a circle of people who can help you because, uh, you know, you don't wanna be... 25:43 It can feel lonely, but it doesn't have to be lonely, is what I'll say. I could not agree more with that. Mike, I appreciate your time. Thank you for joining us. Yep. Everyone who tuned in, of course, thank you as well. 25:54 Please make sure you do the usual rate, review, subscribe, all that fun stuff on whichever podcast platform you prefer, or head over to the ecommshow.com to check out all of our previous episodes. 26:02 But as usual, thank you all for joining us, and we'll see you all next time. Have a good one. [upbeat music] Thank you for tuning in to The E-Comm Show. 26:14 [clapping] Head over to ecommshow.com to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform or on the BlueTuskr YouTube channel. 26:23 The E-Comm Show is brought to you by BlueTuskr, a full service digital marketing company specifically for e-commerce sellers looking to accelerate their growth. Go to bluetuskr.com now for more information. 26:36 Make sure to tune in next week for another amazing episode of The E-Comm Show. [upbeat music]