Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Do your research. We're just very confident that we're the best in this part of the business for Western brands. [upbeat music] And I want a good show, damn it. 0:22 Ready for a good show? Doing awesome. Yeah. [laughs] Excited to talk to you, Andrew. Thanks for having me on. Yes. To build and understand. 0:32 I've always been doing product- Working in archery, and my dad said, "Hey, you guys want to start an archery store?" That's too scary. I'm gonna do that because that's how I roll this week. I agree. Yes, of course. 0:40 That would be the game plan. 0:43 Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of The Ecomm Show. 1:04 I'm your host, as usual, and I'm sorry for that. My name is Andrew Maff, and I am, uh, so excited for today's show. I am joined by Izzy Rosenzweig, who is the CEO of, uh, Portless. 1:16 I was so confident I was gonna get your last name right. It was perfect. I told you. You got it right. [laughs] Yes. Got it. Um, obviously, Rizzy, uh, Izzy, thank you so much. Now I'm gonna butcher your first name now. 1:26 [laughs] Izzy, thank you so much for being on the show. Super excited to have you on the show. I love... This is an area we don't get to talk a lot about, um, 'cause it's just... 1:35 It's so-- It can be so complicated, so I'm so excited to have you on the show so that you can obviously help kind of weed our way through some of those challenges. But obviously, let's do the usual thing. 1:45 Pretend no one knows who you are, and if you can tell me a little bit more about Portless, and we will take it from there. Absolutely. First of all, Andrew, thank you for having me. Very excited to be on your show. 1:54 Uh, high level on myself and the company. My name's Izzy Rosenzweig. I have a company called Portless. Uh, in short, what Portless does, uh, we refer to as direct logistics. 2:04 So if you think about a typical, um, e-commerce business, direct consumer business, the typical supply chain is, let's say I'm selling this polo shirt. I'm gonna manu-manufacture 10,000 polo shirts. 2:14 I'm gonna put them on a boat, and it's gonna take probably around 45, 60, 70 days on water. Mm-hmm. 2:19 And only once it gets to the States am I bringing it over, uh, paying import duties, moving it from the port to my US facility, and only once it's unpacked in my US facility could I start selling to my customers. 2:32 You're looking at two to three months in, in, in a pretty standard supply chain expectation. Yeah. That's a long time to wait to sell inventory. 2:41 Uh, and then once you get the order, then you're shipping it, which takes four to seven days on average across continental US. Yep. That has been e-com since s- really since the beginning. 2:50 Uh, we take a very different approach. So we say, "Hey, once you're done with production, don't put it on a boat. Send it to us." We're based in Shenzhen. 2:57 If you're in the Guangzhou area, we'll get your product within two to three hours. If you're anywhere north or west of China, we get it two to three days. 3:03 But basically, instead of two to three months, two to three days, your product is in our facility. We're connected to Shopify, any software you're, you're selling on. 3:13 Inventory gets fed to you that you now have inventory. You could sell it to your customer. We will deliver it to your customer on average in 5.2 days in the US. USPS driver, USPS tracking number, USPS label, 3:27 100% local experience. So from your end, the consumer's end, 100% make a transaction. Five and a half days later, USP- USPS driver dropping off a package. It got scanned in LA, then delivered to your house in San Diego. 3:39 [lips smack] Local US experience. But for the brand, lead time just went from months to days, so your cash cycle is much faster. Inventory needs go down. Did I need 10,000 shirts? 3:50 Well, I'd need 10,000 shirts when I had to wait three months. Now maybe you have 2,000 shirts, and you could reorder as you're selling. And then the idea of overproduction goes away 'cause you are much more agile. 4:01 And underproduction, when you sell out November 10th of this year, well, typical supply chain, you missed the season. We say, "No, go back to production. November 20th, it's ready. You have Black Friday." Capture demand. 4:13 So that's A, agility in demand, agility in inventory. B, warehousing with us is cheaper. Pick and pack rates are cheaper. No container costs. We don't use containers. No import duties. Section 321, import duty free. 4:25 As long as your average order value is $800 or less... Sorry, under $800, it's import duty free. So no tariffs, no duties. And shipping rates start at five bucks. 4:35 Again, our focus is light items like apparel, cosmetics, jewelry, small electronics, small products. So for those lighter items, great shipping rates. And third thing, we do this in 50 countries around the world. 4:47 UK, Royal Mail. Australia, Australia Post. 4:50 So not only do you have less inventory and, and, and, like, way better cash flow, you now can sell it around the world, cheaper ma- cheaper marketing there, and the consumer always has a local experience. 5:01 That is what we do for Portless. We take a whole different look of logistics and supply chain. [lips smack] You're either the world's best salesman or there's a hole that I'm missing. [laughs] I don't get it. 5:11 How is that... So okay, so you're basically fulfilling directly from China overseas. I don't need to put it on a boat, wait two or three months for it to show up and get to my, my, uh, 3PL or my warehouse, whatever. 5:25 And so, uh, yeah, there's just a huge hole there that I'm missing of, like, I don't understand why is that not a thing already. I know... 5:34 And keep in mind, and as I'm sure all of our listeners know, my knowledge in operations, inventory, all of that is, like, s- impressively low. Mm-hmm. 5:47 So [chuckles] like, it's, it's amazing how long I've been in this industry and how little I know about that side of things. So explain to me how that's not already a thing. 5:56 Why is, why are we not just delivering straight to the consumer at least a portion of the inventory directly from overseas? I'll explain why. 6:04 So first of all, this business has been around-- this model has been around for over 10 years. I've been around in this business model for almost as long as it's been around. Now, it does exist. 6:12 How does Shein run their supply chain? How does Temu run their supply chain, right? Mm-hmm. They're using this supply chain. Now, they're not very good at giving the local experience. 6:20 They're gonna have China tracking number very often from them. Yeah. We know how to separate the, the last mile from the first mile and give that consumer a US experience. But it's been around for a long time. 6:29 Now, the reason why only now is it getting-- only now are we helping other brands do this at, at a much more aggressive scale, 'cause only in the last two and a half years did, A, it become a 100% local US experience. 6:43 It used to have Mandarin on the tracking number, Mandarin on the label, right? So it would be very confusing for consumers. It wouldn't be very relevant for American brands. 6:50 But now it's 100% local US experience, and speed time is now five and a half days, right? Where it used to be two weeks for delivery, 'cause it went down a different model. 6:58 It used to go down, like, the ePacket China Post model. We don't do that model. So the last two and a half, three years, 7:04 the direct injection model, which means we get orders, we put it on pallet, we sort it based on where the U- where the customer's in the US, put it on pallets, and then we put it on air cargo planes. 7:13 If you think about it, how long is a flight? Well, a flight from China to the US- Yeah... you know, 14 to fif- 15 hours on average. Mm-hmm. That means overnight it can be in the US. 7:22 So the idea of getting something here very fast makes sense, and we hand it to USPS near the customer. We do injection in California, Chicago, New York, Arizona, Texas, Miami, Atlanta. 7:32 So no matter where you are, we're handing it to USPS near your cu- near where the customer is, so zone one, zone two. So really, this business model's been around for a long time. 7:42 It wasn't very good for the last 10 years. The last two and a half, three years, it got to extremely good. 7:47 And now, again, not for everybody, 'cause this is models built for lighter products, like apparel's big, cosmetics, jewelry, small electronics, small accessories. 7:57 For very heavy stuff, you know, you're not gonna send a microwave or you're not gonna send a fridge down this model. Yeah. 'Cause the pallet needs to hold many different orders in order for the economics to make sense. 8:06 Yeah. But as long as your stuff are light, we-- there's no stop off at a 3PL. It's on a plane that that night handed to USPS, delivered to your customer's front door, fully local experience. 8:17 So this model only got really relevant the last two and a half, three years. You know, Shein and Temu, Quince, Cider, they've been using it for a very long time. 8:26 We help American brands, European brands for Europe leverage it as well. We're just the supply chain part of this business. But what about, w- what about, like, from a cost structure? 8:37 'Cause obviously I understand, like, to your point, you know, going by air, yes, it's faster. You can order stuff by air, but it's extremely more expensive than taking it by boat. So if a, if a D2C brand is leveraging, 8:52 is basically leveraging this model, so they're leveraging Portless obviously, they are-- Is their cost for shipping to the customer, like, significantly higher or is it- No. Is it-- How does that work? 9:04 So the big caveat is it depends on the brand, meaning what's the size of your product? Yeah. Let's say your product is, is a pound, right? Very good chance your shipping rates and our shipping rates were very similar. 9:15 Why is that? First of all, if your stuff is small, think the biggest cost structure of a pallet on a plane is the, the, uh, volumetric or actual weight on the plane. Mm-hmm. 9:24 Let's give the extreme example 'cause it will make it simpler. A pair of earrings. How much space does that take on a pallet? How many pairs of earrings can I put on a pallet? Yeah. Probably a thousand earrings. 9:34 Think about, okay, uh, apparel, probably 4,000 orders. That means the cost per order is quite low. 9:39 Now, if I was doing pallet to go to my fulfillment center to then take it apart and then reship the full continental US, yes, it's expensive. 9:48 But if the, if the pallet is halfway to your customer's front door, 'cause we're sorting it and we're not stopping off anywhere, we're going right to your customer's front door, that flight is half the, um, the delivery to your customer's front door. 10:00 So as long as your products are on the lighter end, shipping rates start at five bucks. Under five bucks, $4.80. We could do for-- door to door from our floor to your customer's front door. 10:11 Now, you think it's bulkier and heavier? Yes, it does get more expensive. Then you could say, one second, even if it's bulkier and heavier, how much am I saving on import duties, right? 10:19 Some products are 43% import duties. That goes away. That could be $5 per order. So sometimes, very often apples to apples will be very competitive. 10:28 The heavier and bulkier stuff is, the more expensive it is, and all of a sudden it's- Yeah... not apples. Then okay, what are you paying in warehousing? What are you paying on pick and pack? 10:35 What are you paying on import duties? And all that matters to your true landed cost of goods. Yeah. Huh. Okay. So 10:45 what would stop-- And honestly, like, you came in with such a great sales pitch that I was like, "Okay, I gotta find a way that this-- There's gotta be a reason this doesn't work, because I don't know anyone doing this." 10:55 If, if you-- What's keeping sellers from getting a 3PL, like, in China? Great question. Okay. So first off we say is, "Who's gonna do it right now?" There are brands doing it for themselves. Mm-hmm. 11:08 There's people like us, and there's, let's call it local Chinese 3PLs. They do not understand the US market. 11:14 They don't understand to-- the way to keep it localized, uh, the localized experience, not having China- Yeah... working, et cetera. So there just isn't that many options. 11:23 We say, "Hey, if you wanna do it yourself, go ahead." It took us two years to set up legals. You need a Hong Kong corporation, you need a Chinese corporation, roofies, local, uh, directors, KYCs. 11:33 We've been doing this for 10 years, this model, so we know this model inside out. At the end of the day, like a AWS, who wants to build a data center? 11:42 You're actually more cost effective going to AWS yourself, 'cause you're sharing costs across the board. So we say like, "Hey, if you want to, go ahead. Uh, we're just doing this for a long time. 11:50 We're really well priced. We'll probably save you more money than you are today. You just have upside." So we would say no downside, you know, you know, free, uh, free world out there. Do your research. 12:00 We're just very confident that we're the best in this part of the business for Western brands. Huh, cool. 12:07 So, uh, uh, obviously one of the questions I'm thinking is like, okay, is this like, uh, is this kind of like the beginning of what we would assume is like the future of D2C fulfillment? Like- Mm-hmm... 12:19 I know, uh, you know, we work with 200 something different brands at this point, and I can't think of anyone off the top of my head that is doing this type of model. So what... 12:31 A- and I know to your point, obviously, it's a lower, you know, lower price point, maybe smaller product or something like that. Obviously, I guess lower price point doesn't matter, but smaller products helps out. Yep. 12:38 So like what's... what do you think is where is overall fulfillment going? And one of the other questions I gotta ask too, what did we learn from this model during like the COVID times? 12:50 'Cause I know that threw a lot of stuff, and, and that was mostly a port issue, so if you're bringing it in by flight, that's not really a problem, right? Zero delays. Not a single delay. 12:59 When ports were backed up for five to eight weeks, we had zero delays. Planes were leaving every single day. There was a bit of a bump in cost of, of, um, uh, pricing, but not much, like 5%. Um, no delays on COVID. 13:12 But to answer the, the, the original question, my... I- okay, D2C has gotten smashed in the public markets. Look at any D2C brand public markets. Yeah. They look terrible. Mm-hmm. But why are they terrible? 13:25 Demand is there, right? There's a heav- $176 billion of D2C transaction in the United States alone. The problem is to service that demand. If there's demand, there's always gonna be someone servicing it. 13:35 The question is a good business model. So in the, in the current model, terrible cash flow. Every time you sell something, you gotta wait two, three months- Yeah... to sell it again. Uh, lead times are killing you. 13:44 Your gross margins are tight. You out of stock. You overstock production hits your bottom line. So it, it's, it's hard, right? 13:51 Like you're having great production overseas, but you're trying to like be agile, and you can't. I believe this is the early days of, uh, of... 13:58 Again, not every brand could do this, but brands that fit in this model, lighter products, this changes it. 14:03 You have the demand, they're gonna have the same experience that they had yesterday, and you're gonna have an incredible cash flow business. Fast, fast iteration. Think about like software business as fast iteration. 14:12 In e-com, it's like six months. We're like, "No." Go to production, you go put on your e-commerce site, you have m- maybe 2,000 pieces, you're selling really well, go back into production. 14:21 You're getting feedback you want a, a bigger pocket, your next production run is a bigger pocket. It's the future is in, I believe, a different... 14:31 You, you can't play the same game as Walmart and Amazon and be successful. Yeah. 14:34 You must play a different game, and the, the future of this logistics give you great cash flow, and it'll also be the future of manufacturing is small batch manufacturing. 14:43 Now, small batch manufacturing isn't for every industry. The more custom it is, you can't do it, but apparel, it's machines. 14:50 Uh, as long as you have the raw materials locked up, you could move into small batch manufacturing, which means you can have agile inventory, you can have agile, fast feedback loops. I believe that changes the game. 15:00 You now you have demand, you have brands servicing it with better gross margin, better cash flow, and I think in, you know, let's call it the next five years, you're gonna see really profitable D2C brands. 15:11 You know, money's no longer free. We need to be profitable and get very cash flow businesses. But at the core now, this model, they're great businesses. Yeah. 15:20 Interesting, 'cause I, I, I mean, look, obviously I know like that's the big area that it... That was actually kind of leading into my next question of like when you're... 15:28 I'm, I'm basically just gonna ask you for your straight sales pitch 'cause I'm imagining this is the answer. Okay. 15:32 'Cause right, it always comes down to ROI at the end, and so the thing that the, the customer experience makes a ton of sense. Great. 15:39 I still have the US-based side, but from a, a revenue pers- or sorry, from a profitability perspective, I'm not really gonna see a difference there. I just, the customer experience is gonna be improved. 15:48 However, the main point being like, okay, we went through pick and pack, we went through what are your 3PL costs, like that kind of stuff. Like, okay, now I'm, I'm understanding a little bit more. 15:56 But how are you justif- how, how does a, how does a brand justify the add, the, like the actual added benefit of now I don't have to wait for cash for two to three months? 16:08 Like how do you even factor that in to your cost? Because I kinda see that as like a, okay, 16:14 at the same time I could take a loan at X percent and deal with that, and then I gotta do that every few months or whatever, but like how are, how do you factor that in when you're trying to justify if it's doable for a brand or not? 16:24 Honestly, our, the brands that we service get immediate cash flow and immediate margin increases. You don't need to g- That's pretty sophisticated. 16:32 If you're looking at your loan cost, and you take that cost, and you divide it by the amount of units you have- Yeah... you could get a cost per unit loan money. We wouldn't go that sophisticated. 16:42 You're saving money way before that. So A, your cash flow is game changing. You know, D- most D2C brands go out of business 'cause of cash flow more than gross margin. Yeah. 16:50 So, so let's just say that is very obvious from months to days. Then all of a sudden your warehousing, pick and pack rates, we charge a dollar. Most of them charge, you know, $1.50, $2.50. 16:59 Our warehousing's a fraction of the cost. Our shipping rates are cheap. Import duties. 17:03 Think about if you're an apparel brand and you're spending 43% on import duties, let's say anywhere from 20% to 43%, that means per unit you're spending $2 to $5. That goes away. Section 321. 17:15 It's been around for, you know, people been using Mexico for a long time, right? Yeah. Say same thing as Mexico, but you also have advantages as lead times. So you, you don't need to look hard to save money. 17:25 You should be saving money day one, very obvious places, and improving cash flow. 17:30 Now, you have-- we have a bucket of customers that there are stuff on the heavier side, so okay, they might not be saving money, they may be breaking even or maybe they're even paying 50 cents more, but cash flow. 17:40 There's money in the bank all the time. So like the lighter your product ma- the lighter your product is, you'll see potentially net less cost in your, in your model- Yeah... in your, in your cost structure. 17:53 I mean, I can definitely see how it completely varies on like a per brand basis. Yeah. Or even a, on a per product ba- Do you have brands that like, "Hey, we're gonna do this, but only for certain products"? 18:04 Uh, usually we start off that way. So brands very often that, that start us off like, "Hey, let's try three, three SKUs and see how it goes." 18:10 Almost always, I can't think-- Like, some of the people's wholesale business they don't do with us, and we'll put on a boat for them. We'll do FBA injection for them. But once people try us, and we say crawl, walk, run. 18:20 Like, we are your support. Yeah. Like, you go do manufacturing, but, like, we understand we're one of your most important partners here. So we're like, "Hey, try three products." It goes well. "Do you like it? 18:29 Send another 10 products. Send another 30 products." So the-- very often we do that, it's about testing your model. 18:35 But almost always, I can't even think offhand of anyone that doesn't end up ra- Like we s- we have customers in the middle of the process, but most customers end up going, um, 100% of their business with us. 18:47 Um, you have enterprise. Okay, enterprise, then we have partial, because enterprise, they might have physical retail stores. Yeah. And physical retail stores, you need local inventory to restock stores. 18:57 So in that case, we end up getting their best-selling products. We end up getting, uh, collections, uh, drops, if you think about, like, someone drops. If you think about, you know all those drops that people do? 19:05 Like, we work- Mm-hmm... with some really big, um, influencers. They'll do a drop. 19:09 The way they used to do it is do, you know, drop 10,000 units, then put on a boat, and the customer had to wait 60 days post-production for them to get it. That is, like, the longest delivery time ever. Yeah. 19:18 So these guys, you know, it could be either enterprise businesses for, like, um, certain drops of their seasonal lines or influencers, you know, two days post-production, you're shipping to your customer. 19:28 Eight days, you know, six days later, uh, if they're in, you know, parts of Asia or wherever they are, uh, maybe longer, but pretty quickly after, they have a delivery. 19:36 So those are areas that we see where we get some of the product, not all the product. How do you decipher who's a good fit and who's not? 19:45 I-- It sounds like the pretty obvious is like, hey, if you've got a smaller product, chances are this is gonna line up for you. 19:50 But at what point do you go, "Okay, now once your product gets over X size, if your price point isn't over X, it may not be justifiable for you"? Yeah, exactly. 20:00 Um, I would say over five pounds, very often they're, "Okay, your, your order's over five pounds, you're probably not gonna be successful here." Um, let's do the math. What's your import duties like? 20:09 What's your cash flow needs? Yeah. What are you currently paying locally? Sometimes these products are, like, funky-looking products, and they're paying a lot locally. 20:15 But I would say if I had to, like, rule of thumb, above five pounds, we'll get complex. Under five pounds, again, apparel, cosmetics, jewelry, small electronics- Yeah... 20:22 accessories, usually pretty interesting conversat- like, we'll have a pretty interesting conversation. Yeah. Um. 20:28 But if it's over five pounds and it's a higher, let's say, AOV or just the individual product is a higher price point, it then could theoretically- Exactly... still be justifiable, right? 20:36 Exactly, because then you could be saving 40 bucks in import duties, right? Yeah. So it's a good sign. And we have scenarios like that. Uh, or they wanna try international markets. 20:44 Let's just say their stuff is heavy, but they wanna test Europe. They've never tested Europe. Well, we can help you test Europe really easily, uh, from one hub next to your factory. 20:53 So there's always, like, those cases, but, like, core ICP, 'cause we mainly focus on people's main markets, like US for US brands, you know, Europe for European brands. 21:02 Um, you know, if you're under five pounds, we'll have a really interesting conversation. Yeah. Izzy, this was awesome. Your excitement for this was- Yeah... it made me excited about operations, which is very hard to do. 21:13 [laughs] Um, so obviously, I really appreciate you having you on the show. I'd love to give you an opportunity, let everyone k- know where they can find out more about you and, of course, more about Portless. 21:21 Thank you so much. Again, thank you so much for having me. This has been super fun. I do get very excited by supply chain. I consider myself a supply chain nerd. 21:27 So if I got you excited, I, I get very excited- It's great... by that. [laughs] Um, you can find us on portless.com. Uh, we have all the information, case studies, videos. Uh, contact us there. 21:37 I'm pretty active on LinkedIn and, and X, uh, always posting content, uh, posting videos. Uh, anything you wanna learn, just send me a DM there. 21:46 Uh, we'd love the opportunity to connect with anyone that thinks that they could benefit from this model. Love it. Thank you so much for being on the show. Obviously, everyone who tuned in, thank you as well. 21:55 Please make sure you do the usual, rate, review, subscribe, all that fun stuff, on whichever podcast platform you prefer, or head over to the ecommshow.com to check out all of our previous episodes. 22:02 But as usual, we will see you all next time. Have a good one. [upbeat music] Thank you for tuning in to The E-Com Show. 22:10 Head over to ecommshow.com to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform or on the BlueTuskr YouTube channel. 22:18 The E-Com Show is brought to you by BlueTuskr, a full-service digital marketing company specifically for e-commerce sellers looking to accelerate their growth. Go to bluetuskr.com now for more information. 22:31 Make sure to tune in next week for another amazing episode of The E-Com Show. [upbeat music]