Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] I think that the biggest misunderstanding getting into it is just, you know, the amount of time and the amount of money it takes to, to launch a brand. 0:16 And I want a good show, damn it. You ready for a good show? Doing awesome. Yeah. I'm excited to talk to you, Andrew. Thanks for having me on. Yes. Yeah. 0:32 Fell in this, you know, and I've always been doing private- working in archery, and my dad said, "Hey, let's go start an archery store." That's one scenario that I think is, that's how I would respond. Finally, yes, 0:44 of course. Let me begin. 0:45 Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of The E-Comm Show. 1:05 I'm your host, Andrew Maff. And today, I'm joined by the amazing Chris Gallant, who's the CEO of Chamberlain Coffee. Chris, how you doing, man? You ready for this? You ready for a good show? Awesome start. I got this. 1:15 [laughs] I am. Let's do it. Beautiful. Uh, super excited to have you on the show. I'm a big coffee fan. I also know your background is nuts, so I do wanna get into that as well. 1:26 Um, so obviously, I always like to let you do the honors of that, start it off the stereotypical way. Tell us a little bit about your background, you know, where you were at. We'll get into Chamberlain Coffee next. Yeah. 1:37 Um, my background is beverages. I lo- I love drinks. Um, and so I've been in the beverage world since about 2009, have worked for some large companies like Heineken, uh, and Red Bull, in strategy and M&A teams. 1:51 Uh, started a brewery in New York and sold it. Um, worked in kombucha for a while, and now I'm here. 1:56 So, you know, I've, I've been, uh, I've been in beverages for most of my career, whether consulting for them or working for them or leading them. Uh, so having a lot of fun, uh, now selling coffee. 2:07 So beverages i- in, in all of the CPG space, food and bev- beverages are a pain. Like, they can be really tough to get going. 2:18 And you've now worked with, as you mentioned, I know it was Heineken, Red Bull, you had the brewery, kombucha. Yes. Now you've gotten into coffee, which is a very [laughs] different direction out of those. 2:26 But what, uh... Like, w- what kinda got you into the industry in the first place? Yeah, I, for sure, I wish I knew how hard it was [laughs] before I chose this path. 2:37 Um, you know, it's, uh, it's, it's difficult, it's competitive, and it's very expensive. Uh- Yeah... but what, what got me into it? Let's see. 2:44 I, uh, I was consulting, uh, for, um, for a large consulting firm in the US, had an opportunity to go work for a beverage company, um, traveling around the Caribbean, uh, helping them assess their operations in different islands. 3:00 So I jumped on the opportunity to do that project, fell in love, and, uh, and took it up from there. Wow. The... And so obviously you alluded to, and as I did as well, the- Yeah... 3:11 the beverage space is just, it's very difficult. There's a ton of beverages that are launched all the time and then fail- Mm-hmm... all the time. 3:20 You've obviously had experience in a lot of different name brand, uh, beverages, and Chamberlain Coffee's obviously growing like a weed right now. 3:27 So, like, what do you see as the big mistake that a lot of these different beverage companies make when they first go to launch? 3:36 Yeah, I think that's a great que- I mean, there's so many mistakes to be made, and I've made most of them myself. 3:40 I mean, there's, um, I think understanding what it takes to, um, to build the companies overall is, is the hardest thing, right? So it takes time, um, and it takes a lot of investment upfront. 3:53 E- even if you are co-packing or making it with another manufacturer, it takes investment to develop a product, to buy all the inventory, the raw materials, to hold that inventory, uh, and then to, um, to get it on shelf, right? 4:08 It costs money to get a product on shelf, and it costs money to get the product to come off shelf, right? Especially- Yeah... 4:13 if you're a new brand with- without brand awareness, you- you've just gotta invest so much behind trade spend. 4:20 And if we're talking about retail, you gotta invest a lot of money behind promos to get people to sample your product. 4:26 'Cause if you're just a new product on shelf, uh, and no one's heard of you, no one's gonna take you maybe unless you're on deal or unless you're visible with an off-shelf display so they can try you. Mm-hmm. 4:36 And then they'll come back and tr- and keep buying you if you're great, but you've gotta get that first purchase. 4:40 And if you're talking about e-com, again, you've, you've gotta spend money behind, um, you know, paid media. You've gotta spend money behind building a social presence to get people to be aware of you. So- Yeah... 4:50 yeah, I think that the biggest misunderstanding getting into it is just, you know, the amount of time and the amount of money it takes to, to launch a brand. 4:58 Let, let's talk about the e-com side for a second, 'cause that side's always- Yeah... very interesting. You know, we've worked with a ton of beverage brands that, you know, they're coming straight out the gate. 5:06 They wanna get started and get things moving. And I know that the difficulty, especially with anything in CPG, is just you've gotta get someone to try something. But for beverage- Mm-hmm... 5:17 it's so expensive to ship because y- you've gotta- Right... you know, basically sell them at least, like, a 12-pack or something like that to actually get them to make that purchase. 5:25 So what do you do in the beginning stages to get people to actually try things b- uh, over the internet before they actually commit to a larger order? Or are you solely relying- Yeah... on the promos in store? 5:39 Great question. We actually didn't come out with a beverage until three years into the business. So we started out with coffee, so dry coffee, bags of coffee or tins- Yeah... of matcha. 5:49 Uh, and, and, uh, and we still don't sell beverages online for just that reason. I think it's, um, it's really... You're right. 5:56 You re- you've got to, when you're selling beverages, you've gotta sell a multi-pack, preferably at least a 12-pack, to make the economics work. 6:03 Now, the challenge with that is you're asking people to spend, you know, $30 to $40, maybe more, uh- And that's a high ring for somebody to sample something. 6:11 For someone who's never tried something, you know, 30 to $40 potentially, plus shipping is, is a lot of money to spend if you've never tried or even heard of a brand. Yeah. 6:20 And so, um, now that we, now that we do have the brand awareness, we're going to be bringing some of our beverages online. Uh, but it's, it's taken us... So we launched beverages a little over a year ago. 6:30 It's taken us a year to get there. Yeah. Now, so for the coffee side specifically, I know it can be a little bit different, right? But the coffee side is so wildly competitive. 6:39 Everyone and their mother likes to just- Mm-hmm... go find beans and slap a label on it, and then say that they have their own coffee brand. Right. 6:45 And that is a nightmare scenario because it's just another me-too product. Coffee, I understand a little bit different because the economics of it still line up. 6:54 The shipping doesn't have to be as crazy as if you were selling a 12-pack or something. But still, it's that beginning, like, how do you get people to actually try the coffee? 7:04 Did you start off with, like, smaller, like, samplers that were just like a, you know, kind of free plus shipping kind of thing? Or what was that initial approach? Yeah. 7:13 I mean, look, we have, we have a head start because, because my partner has such a loud voice, uh, online, right? She, she started as a YouTuber, has an amazing podcast. 7:22 So we had a bit of a head start to make people aware of our brand and get them to sample it. Um, but you're right. It's, you know, it's, it's hard to get people to try things. Um, and so you wanna balance out having 7:33 a product that is, um, at a low enough cost, you know, per unit, price per unit, so that people are willing to say, "Oh, I can try this for 10 or $20." Um, but that's also enough to, to cover your economics over time. 7:48 Yeah. Right? And so that's, you know, one of the great things about coffee is it comes in at that price point. You know, we're... We charge about $16 a bag. 7:55 And so that's, that's not a big ring for consumers to try a new product. Now, shipping out a bag of coffee, that's, uh, you know, if we're just shipping one bag, right, that, that economics, those economics don't work. 8:07 Yeah. 8:07 And so we have to try to get them through incentives or through bundles or through, um, you know, through add-ons to instead of buying a bag of coffee a month, buy, you know, a bag of coffee and a mug and a tin of matcha. 8:21 And then two months later, come back and buy something else. Yeah. So you brought up, uh, your partner, which I did wanna ask you about. So Emma Chamberlain, ob- obviously the namesake of the brand. 8:31 Um, one thing I've noticed about your brand specifically, when I've, you know, seen a lot of brands that have an influencer tied to them, and most of the time the influencer's face is, like, stapled all over the website. 8:44 Mm-hmm. And you guys went in a different direction with that. I think from what I was able to find, Emma's only referenced, like, in a couple sentences, like in your About section kind of thing. 8:51 So what was the thought process around leveraging her influence, but not catering to it with the brand? Yeah. Uh, it's a great question. I think, um... 9:04 So obviously the, the brand is her namesake, so it's, it's intimately tied to her brand as well. Yeah. 9:09 But, you know, what we see is a lot of, a lot of creators, a lot of celebrities promoting brands, um, a little bit too much. Maybe not a little bit, a lot too much. Yeah. 9:22 And I think that leads to, uh, this inauthenticity, 9:26 that over time consumers, you know, won't believe them as much as they're promoting things, won't believe that, you know, celebrity A really does believe in this product that he or she, uh, probably doesn't use, right? 9:40 Yeah. [laughs] Uh, and so we, you know, we really want the brand to feel authentic to Emma. Uh, because ultimately she isn't just the face of our brand, she's the founder of our brand. Uh, she's a board member. 9:51 She's one of the key, uh, day-to-day players in it, right? And so we, we take a pretty deliberate role with her about how much should we promote this. 9:59 You know, it probably shouldn't be every day, maybe not even every week. Now, on our own page, we're promoting the heck out of it. But, you know, for her, uh, we wanna make sure it still feels authentic to consumers. 10:09 Yeah. For... 10:12 So a- and, you know, kinda to that point, like, I know, like, influencers, their reach can only get you so far, and then at a certain point you kinda hit a wall of, okay, we've either more or less gotten to all of the people that you have an influence on or, you know, we're just kinda hitting a wall with who we can contact. 10:29 So in your scenario, in terms of marketing outside of leveraging her brand, what has that been like? I know, uh, there's a lot going on on an e-commerce, like online perspective. 10:39 I know you're also leaning heavier into the, um, uh, retail side of things. So, like, what's that whole approach been? Yeah. I think, I think any celebrity can get you that first look, right, or their first sample. 10:52 People will go try it, but beyond that, you've got to, to get those people coming back, you've gotta have a great product to have them keep coming back to buy your product again. 11:01 If you look at, you know, our, uh, our sales in e-com every day, you know, a big chunk of it is returning consumers, the people coming back to buy again and again. 11:10 I think the other thing is, you know, celebrities don't reach every person in the US. Mm-hmm. And so you've gotta create a brand that can stand on its own as well. 11:18 And so we try to create, um, a fun, unique, different brand or their own brand voice that speaks to consumers. 11:24 So if you go down the coffee aisle, uh, at retail, right, you'll see lots of brown and, and drab colors, and you see our bright pink and purple packaging, and it's, it's something else that's, it's sort of jumping out to consumers. 11:34 So that's part of it, is creating its own brand, and part of it is, you know, we've, we've gotta do all the nuts and bolts that any brand that, that doesn't have, uh, a celebrity, uh, on it, right? Yeah. 11:46 So we've got to, uh, spend money on paid media, right? We've gotta work with micro-influencers. At retail we have to do price promotions to get people that have never heard of us or Emma to try the product. 11:57 We've gotta do, you know, shelf talkers, put up piece, you know, big cardboard stands. So we've gotta do it all as well. Yeah. Are you kinda... 12:06 'Cause to your point, most of e-commerce seems to be from returning customers, so are you kinda using retail as like a customer acquisition channel and trying to get them to come back to, uh, e-com? Or are you kinda... 12:18 doing a blend of the two I'd say it's actually the other way around, right? Because as you, as you look at, um, and, and this is, this is the hard part about e-commerce, right? 12:27 On a gross margin basis, e-commerce is a, a much more profitable channel for us, right, than, than retail is. Yeah. 12:34 But if you start to look on a fully loaded contribution margin basis and start to look at the cost of acquiring consumers, the cost of shipping product, um, retail starts to become a much more profitable channel. 12:46 Uh, and there's much, much more volume there. And so as we push more into retail, we start to look at e-commerce as something special for our consumers. 12:55 So a point we can interact with them, a point we can talk, uh, with the consumers that really wanna engage with our brand, and, uh, a discovery tool, right? And then retail is a real growth engine for our business. Yeah. 13:08 Interesting. So it's a very interesting way to look at that. So it-- so if you're looking at the e-commerce side as the customer acquisition channel trying to kind of focus on, hey, you know, we're available in retail. 13:19 From your paid media perspective, are you keeping that focused in areas only where you're available in retail, or are you doing like a full nationwide and just check out your local, local store kind of thing? Yeah. 13:32 So I mean, we're, we're in a bunch of nationwide retailers, so we really, we push it, I think... What's the stat? It's, like, 90-something percent of America lives within five miles of a Walmart, right? 13:40 And we're in all the Walmarts. So we, um- There you go... you know, we really push it pretty, pretty nationwide. 13:46 Um, and we're starting to do a mix of ads, and we're starting to experiment with what does it look like as we maybe do an ad that's not focused on bringing somebody to our, our own D2C site, but directing that paid media to, um, to Instacart, uh, and one of our, one of our partners, right? 14:03 Or maybe to Amazon, 'cause a lot of people use Amazon as a, uh, you know, replacement for the grocery store. So we're starting to experiment what that looks like. 14:11 That, you know, really messes with what our, uh, you know, our ROAS and our CAC figures look like over time because all of a sudden we're spending ads and directing people away from our site. Yeah. 14:21 Uh, but I think ultimately it's, it's healthy for the business. And so, okay, so you're also available on Amazon? We are, yes. Interesting. Okay. 14:31 So you're-- So yeah, so that actually, then that brings up a great question. 14:35 If you're, uh, adjusting paid media to potentially go to one of those channels where you can't measure attribution and you also have a lot of people that you know there's bleed over and they're going to retail, how do you put together your target KPIs for things like paid media or any of your marketing initiatives from an e-commerce perspective, knowing that it's going to have an effect from an off, uh, uh, w-website perspective, as well as probably your Amazon or Instacart or Walmart, et cetera? 15:04 That's a great question. I was gonna ask you the same thing. I mean, I think- [laughs]... you know, I talk to 15:09 a lot, a lot of other people, uh, you know, that are running brands that, that went from D2C into retail, and it's, it's a pretty common thing, right? 15:17 Especially for brands that started during COVID and had, you know, such an uplift from the massive, uh, the massive off, off-trend uptick, right- Yeah... during, of e-commerce during COVID. 15:26 But, you know, taking their brand now to retail to really grow it, how do they measure that, uh, success? 15:32 And I, I don't think anyone has found a great measure yet of saying like, "Okay, now I take 15% of my budget and I direct that towards retail." It's really hard to measure. 15:41 You can start to try it by doing it on a geography basis. Say I've got, you know, X chain in the Pac Northwest, and I'll just, you know, pump a bunch of paid media in the Pac Northwest to see if, if there's an uplift. 15:54 And you can start to do some of that, but it's really hard to measure the impact of, uh, of online, uh, digital media against- Yeah... against offline sales. 16:04 It's always comforting to me when I ask that question to a business that's run like yours and you're like, "I don't, I don't know." I'm like, "Good. Okay." [laughs] "Just making sure that it's not just me." 16:13 I do feel like- We're, we're working on it. We're, we're trying to figure it out, but it's, it's really, it's really hard to measure. I mean, there is- Oh, yeah... 16:18 there's obviously-- we, we know there's some impact, right? Because we know that, you know, just functionally people see an ad online, that doesn't just mean they buy something online. It will impact- Yeah... 16:27 their purchase behavior at the grocery store. And so you can try to look at an aggregate by geography, but that's kind of the only measure we've seen so far- Yeah... we can kind of see if it works. 16:38 Nick, I've, I've s- felt like as time has gone on, especially as, you know, attribution has gotten stripped away and things like that, like digital marketing is really becoming very similar to traditional marketing. 16:49 Like you can't paint the picture of an ROI of a billboard. So like you, you're looking at marketing collectively. And my favorite example was actually ironically it was coffee. Was watching my wife shop. 17:01 She got hit from an Instagram ad, clicked on the ad, went to their website, went from their website and searched, seen they were available on Amazon, thought they looked good, wanted to see if she could get a discount, went back to the website, forgot their name so we had to Google them, clicked on their Google ad, went to the website and converted. 17:17 I was like, look, from a, as a marketing standpoint, I hate you. [laughs] Like I have no- Yeah... idea how to decide what worked there. 17:25 And because that customer journey is so fluid now, it's like you can't really paint that picture as much as you want. It's much harder. 17:34 I mean, look, when I worked at Red Bull, we built, you know, giant ice mountains in baseball parks- [laughs]... and had downhill ice skating races. Like how do you, how do you measure that cost [laughs]- Yeah... 17:44 against the success of the brand, right? 17:46 Well, you'd think like, a-and correct me if I'm wrong, but at a brand at that size, and I would imagine also at Heineken, it's really more of your focus, your marketing initiatives are a little bit more focused on just eyeballs and not so much actual conversion because you kind of assume X amount of eyeballs are pretty much guaranteed to get us X amount of sales, correct? 18:07 Yeah. At, at that measure, yes, right? You start to see what the impact is of, of building an ice mountain, right? In different types- [laughs]... you know, in that specific geography, right? 18:15 But then also, right, in terms of what media do you get out of that. And now you can kind of see, you know, as you put that on social media, what happens and how many eyeballs do you get there. Yeah. 18:24 But it's not quite as easy to see I'm gonna run a price promotion in, you know, this chain in central Ohio, and let's see what the lift is out of it. Yeah. Uh, so I digress, going back to Chamberlain. 18:37 Um, what do you, how do you kind of position the brand? Like, when you first, uh, uh, started with Chamberlain, like, did you figure out exactly how, like, where the hole in the market was? 18:47 'Cause, like I'd mentioned earlier, like, coffee is a wildly competitive space. 18:51 So how did you figure out, like, "Okay, here's how we can really connect with an audience that seems to not have that representation right now"? Yeah. 19:00 I look from a consumer and from a, um, a brand standpoint, a lot of it stemmed from Emma and her audience, right? Mm-hmm. And her method of communicating with fans and her voice, and so that worked really well for us. 19:12 So that was, that was an easy part to figure out. I think as far as products go, is it was more trial and error, right? And so it was trying to understand how our consumers 19:21 wanna drink coffee, because it's, it's not like I'm drinking it now, right? Sort of hot, uh, coffee, black in the morning, right? They wanna drink it cold. They wanna drink it, you know, sweeter. 19:30 They wanna drink it at different occasions throughout the day in different formats. So, you know, it took a lot of, took a lot of work for us to say, "Okay, this format works. This doesn't. 19:39 You know, this type of roast works. This doesn't. This flavor profile works. This doesn't." So, um, you know, part of it is listening to consumers and, and, uh, hearing what they say. 19:47 Um, you know, s- sometimes what they say they want isn't always, you know, what they'll actually buy. [laughs] Thanks a lot. So part of it is trial and error. 19:54 Part of it's looking at what other brands are doing, either in our category, adjacent categories. But, um, it's really triangulating all those data points- Yeah... and seeing what works. 20:04 What about from, like, a retention perspective? 'Cause like I said, co- uh, coffee's just so competitive that it's always interesting to me- Mm-hmm... to speak with someone that broke through that. 20:15 But what do you do to keep them coming back? Obviously, you know, you do the standard auto emails and stuff like that, but, like, uh, like, how do you- Yeah... manage, like, reward programs or anything along those lines? 20:25 Or do you even have those? Yeah, we have a reward program with Super Affiliate, which I think works really well for us. Um, we have a subscription program with, you know, free shipping, so those things work well. 20:36 Um, it's, was interesting what's happened to our subscription program as we launched on Amazon and as we launched at retail. 20:42 Um, so, you know, as we launched on Amazon, we saw a subscription slow down, and we saw Amazon Subscribe and Save take off like crazy. Oh, yeah. 20:49 Which told us, "Hey, there's just a cohort of consumers that prefer to shop on Amazon, so we've gotta be there, and we've gotta offer them products there if that's their preferred method of purchase." 20:58 Similarly, we, we launched into retail, we saw some subscriptions slow down, and the feedback we got from consumers at the, you know, at the subscription surveys at the end, at the end is, uh, at the end it is, "Hey, I can now buy you at my local Walmart- Right... 21:09 or my local Target, and so I'm gonna buy you there instead." Yeah. Um, and so it made us really start to think about, "Is there something different we can offer on subscription? Is there a, uh, a unique flavor? 21:19 Is there something extra that those diehards that want it s- delivered to them by us should get or can't get?" Yeah. 21:27 Yeah, when I, um, actually, when we first started the E-Comm Show, I had the founder of Bold Commerce, Jay Myers, on the show, and all we did was talk about the subscription side. 21:36 And the complications of getting a good subscription model in place was, well, it was just so eye-opening. It was a great episode. Um- Yeah... I, I completely agree. 21:47 As soon as Am- as soon as you kinda open up the Amazon wormhole, people prefer to s- you know, subscribe and save there. And so, you know, it's a, it's a very clear lesson of diversification. 21:57 Be everywhere that your customer is. Like, in your point, you're on retail. You have your own website. You have Amazon, you have Walmart, Instacart, et cetera. 22:03 So it, it really is a matter of just keep trucking along with what you know is working well, and then just let them shop wherever they're most comfortable. Yeah. 22:13 You know, we, we pushed back against launching on Amazon for a long time. Yeah. [laughs] Um, and then once we did it, it, you know, we once we put a little, little bit of effort behind it, it really took off. 22:22 So again, they told us, "Hey, people wanna buy there." And so, um, you know, why, why fight it? If our consumer, the people that love us, wanna buy in this, in this manner, then let's do it. Yeah, absolutely. 22:33 Chris, really appreciate it. I don't wanna take up too much more of your time. Uh, it was great having you on the show. I appreciate your time. 22:39 I would love to give the opportunity here to let everyone know where they can find out more about you and, of course, more about Chamberlain Coffee. Great. 22:46 Cha- chamberlaincoffee.com or @chamberlaincoffee on all social media. Easy enough. Appreciate it. All right. Thanks again. Everyone who tuned in, of course, thank you as well. 22:56 Please make sure you do the usual rate, review, subscribe, all that fun stuff on whichever podcast platform you prefer, or head over to the ecommshow.com to check out all of our previous episodes. 23:04 But as usual, we'll see you all next time. Have a good one. [upbeat music] Thank you for tuning in to The E-Comm Show. 23:12 Head over to ecommshow.com to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform or on the BlueTuskr YouTube channel. 23:20 The E-Comm Show is brought to you by BlueTuskr, a full service digital marketing company specifically for e-commerce sellers looking to accelerate their growth. Go to bluetuskr.com now for more information. 23:33 Make sure to tune in next week for another amazing episode of The E-Comm Show. [upbeat music]