Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] The phone is like a very kind of intimate space to connect with your consumers, and you wanna make sure that you earn their trust and you maintain that trust over the life cycle of their engagement with you. 0:13 [upbeat music] And I want a good show, damn it. You ready for a good show? Doing awesome. Yeah. Yeah. [laughs] Excited to talk to you, Andrew. Thanks for having me on. 0:31 Yes. Yeah. So I've always been doing a lot in archery, and my dad said, "Hey, let's go start an archery store." That's very interesting. Because that's how I was- I knew, yes, of course that dude is the guest. 0:49 Hello, everyone, and welcome to another episode of The E-Com Show. 1:09 As usual, I'm your host, Andrew Maff. And today, I am joined by the amazing Sara Varney, who is the CMO of Attentive, one of the leading SMS companies. Sara, how you doing? You ready for a good show? I am, yes. 1:20 Thanks so much for having me. I'm excited. I'm also super excited. I have a love-hate relationship with SMS marketing. Uh, we do it all the time here. 1:28 Um, but as a consumer, I also get a lot of them, and so I see pros and cons on both sides. So super excited to dig into this one. Yeah. Uh, and obviously I know to get those answers, you are gonna be perfect for this. 1:40 Um- Yeah. Great... s- s- typical approach, love to hear a little bit, uh, about your background, and tell us a little bit about Attentive. 1:47 We'll pretend no one knows who you guys are, as if, and then, uh, we'll take it from there. Sound good? Yeah. Sounds great. Yeah. So, uh, I'm Sara Varney. I'm the chief marketing officer at Attentive, as you mentioned. 1:57 Uh, prior to Attentive, I was the CMO at Twilio for a number of years, and then started my career in software at Salesforce for over a decade. Uh, so spent a lot of time in the customer experience space. 2:10 Uh, and Attentive is a super exciting company to be at right now. Uh, I really believe that SMS is the, the future of marketing. 2:19 Uh, and we are, uh, to boil it down to, to really the essence of what Attentive is, we are a conversational commerce platform. Uh, we deliver both SMS and email across the, uh, entire retail journey, 2:34 and we wanna make sure that we're creating the most engaging customer experiences so that, uh, people engage with your brand, continue to, uh, buy and become, you know, lifelong customers of, of your products. 2:46 Uh, and so we try to always be thinking about what is the most e- engaging way, uh, to, to really get that customer, uh, hooked, uh, and excited about your products and, or your services. Beautiful. 3:01 Question, the immediate thing that comes to mind, SMS is, uh... it's kind of like the Wild West where, like, it, it's doing really well. 3:10 It's still one of those things, like, marketers haven't ruined it just yet, which is great, but I know that there are, uh... 3:18 there's basically some areas where you can definitely put in some suggestions for us about, like, how often is too often, how few... how little is too little. Like, what are your... 3:28 When you start bringing people on, you have these people really leveraging the platform, and they're just killing it with the platform, what do you see as making sure that they're not overusing it and abusing the, you know, kind of the privilege they've been given from these users? 3:40 And how do you make sure that they're also n- using it enough that all of a sudden someone doesn't get a text one day, and they're like, "I have no idea who this is"? Yeah, absolutely. 3:48 So I think it's really important to not just take your email strategy and bring it over to SMS and use it kind of- Yeah... uh, verbatim. 3:54 I think that SMS is a completely different, uh, animal, and you, l- to your point, you really have to be careful about how you use it. 4:01 The phone is, like, a very kind of intimate space to connect with your, um, consumers, and you wanna make sure that you earn their trust and you maintain that trust over the life cycle of, of their engagement with you. 4:13 Uh, I think what's key, there's no, like, one size fits all to say, like, "Hey, you should only send, you know, two messages a week," or whatever the, like, right formula is. 4:22 Um, I think what is really important is to think about segmentation in a very, um, uh, thoughtful way. 4:29 Uh, I think that there are customers that maybe do only wanna hear from you every so often, or they do only wanna hear about sales, or they only wanna hear about new products. 4:38 Um, but then there are customers that are your biggest fans, and they wanna know every little detail. They do wanna hear from you, um, you know, as often as you have new and, and relevant content. 4:48 And so I think it's really important to identify what lanes each of your prospects or customers are in, and then market to them in a very one-to-one, personalized way. 4:58 Uh, and that's something that, that we really pride ourselves on here at Attentive. 5:03 Um, that's why we're investing really heavily in AI to make sure that we can, uh, identify early on who is falling in what segment and, you know, what the best kind of advice is to, uh, market to those, you know, particular users in the way that they wanna be communicated to. 5:18 Yeah. So i- in terms of frequency on, let's say, just kind of your traditional, like, one-off push, or you have the things that are more triggered based, do you have... 5:30 Like, do you cater a little bit more towards you think it's best to have a lot of the stuff more triggered based? 5:35 I know it's difficult to, for a lot of people when they think like, "Okay, I'm gonna get into SMS," and similar to like you just mentioned, they wanna take their email marketing approach and just duplicate it, and I know that that definitely doesn't work. 5:48 So from, like, a frequency standpoint for your traditional campaigns as opposed to your automations, how do you kind of map out, like, okay, from an automation side, these are the things that you should have in place, but keep in mind, you know, the frequency of your campaigns? 6:03 Yeah, I mean- That it's like, I do think while I, I... Like I said, I don't think you should take your email strategy and completely apply it- Yeah... to the SMS channel, 'cause I think that that's a mistake. 6:13 But I do think that some of the, um, broad strokes approach that marketers take when it comes to thinking about, uh, your funnel i- it still applies for SMS. 6:23 So you're not gonna just do top of funnel awareness or, you know, splashy brand stuff all the time when you're using SMS. 6:30 You also wanna make sure you have that balance of maturing people who have raised their hand and shown interest in something and making sure that they continue through the process. 6:38 So, you know, there might be a high level, uh, broader, you know, broad-based campaign you do for a Labor Day sale, let's say. Mm-hmm. 6:47 And then when people show interest, you wanna make sure you've got those right journeys in place, whether it's cart abandonment or, uh, back in stock, uh, to make sure that anyone that has, you know, raised their hand and shown interest, that you're continuing to promote that product in a very relevant way that's keeping, uh, you know, that experience, uh, top of mind. 7:07 Gotcha. I wish I'd brought you on a little bit sooner, 'cause as of recording this, we're in a good spot. We're right before Q4. 7:14 However, by the time this goes out, we're gonna be, like, in the thick of it, so that makes it kinda tough. But during Q4, obviously similar to what you mentioned about a frequency side, wanna keep that limited, 7:26 what about post Q4, right? Like, I'm a big believer of Q4 is a lot... It, it's better utilized as a customer acquisition time, 'cause a lot of people are willing to try new brands. 7:37 But then what kind of things can you have in place, especially from an SMS standpoint, to make sure that going into the new year, and obviously throughout the year, that you're retaining those customers, you're extending that lifetime value and making a lot more, you know, use of your time from Q4? 7:51 I think it's all about creating experiences that, again, are enjoyable and that also continue to build trust. 7:59 And I think a, a, a key component of that trust is building, uh, campaigns that feel very personalized to that individual. 8:06 So I think about someone like Guess Brands, which is a, a, an Attentive customer, and I thought they did something really cool in, like, the February, March timeframe last year, uh, around spring break, and they had a two-way campaign that they sent via SMS, and they said, "Hey, here are, uh, you know, we're gonna curate the perfect spring break outfit for you. 8:26 Pick your favorite city. Is it Palm Springs? Is it Miami? Is it Scottsdale?" 8:30 And based on how the person responded, you know, 1 for Scottsdale, 2 for Miami, whatever, they would serve back, uh, a curated outfit that matched that location. 8:40 And I thought that was just a really simple, clever way to create an engaging experience that, uh, you know, the customer could see, oh, this is a cool outfit. I don't have to think about, like, piecing stuff together. 8:51 And guess what? Guess gets great information back that they can then go and use in a future quarter to go remarket to that customer. 8:59 So, um, I think in that scenario we're getting that, you know, it's a, it's an enjoyable experience. Uh, it's, like, helping the customer kind of have that personal shopping experience. 9:10 Uh, and it's also building trust with them. 9:12 They know that, like, all right, like, in the, in the next campaign, Guess is gonna even be smarter about marketing that particular individual and, and, and serve up even a, a more relevant image or copy or, um, you know, whatever it might be, that's gonna be like, "All right, Guess gets me. 9:27 Like, I under- Like, they understand kind of what I'm looking for and are not just spamming me." Yeah. In true Guess fashion, I do love that idea. That's a good idea. I like that. 9:36 I might have to look into how to do that. So the... I know a lot of sellers, sometimes they'll just do like a, "Hey, today we have a sale," and, like, that's it, and there's no engagement side of it. 9:45 So do you consistently see better performing SMS when it's more of a two-way thing and you're actually trying to get the user to engage with the message as opposed to just knowing about a sale that's going on? 9:56 I do think that the more personalized the experience is, the more likely you're gonna get someone to bite and be interested in, in what you're promoting. 10:04 That's not to say that sales aren't important, too, and holidays can be huge moments for the brands we work with, 100%. Uh- Yeah... 10:11 but I do think the more that you can get that information from a consumer and s- and be upfront about it, too, that's another way to build trust. Like, "Hey, you know, tell us how much you wanna hear from us. 10:20 Do you wanna hear about resort wear? Do you wanna hear about, uh, you know, new hats? Do you wanna hear about whatever?" And then you can kind of k- you know, play that back to, um, that customer. 10:31 A- and again, it's a moment to, to build trust with them and, uh, you know, they're, they are gonna be less inclined to unsubscribe in that context, 'cause you're, you're not going to be just giving them the same message, whether they're interested in hats or they're interested in w- whatever it is. 10:49 Yeah. Uh, and so, uh, you know, we do definitely see, uh, higher performance and IR- ROI when people focus on those personalized elements. Gotcha. Do... What's the... 11:00 W- what would be the best practice for the actual acquisition, right? Like, a lot of people, giving an email is, i- if here's 10% off, and then, like, they just do it, and then they go and delete it. 11:11 SMS, it's definitely a little bit more of a hesitation. 11:13 So do you have a best practice in mind or basically something that you usually say, like, "Hey," when you're trying to get an S, uh, trying to get someone's phone number, like, here's an approach that you can do so it's not too, 11:26 what's the word I want here? Not, I guess not too salesy to a certain extent, but then do you also have an idea of what they should be saying as soon as they sign up? 11:37 I, um, I think that we've definitely seen different signup units, uh, have, uh, improved performance. For example, our spin-to-win, uh, signup unit that we, uh, see a lot of our customers use. 11:49 You know, it's just a simple spinning wheel, and you- people will land on a particular discount. 11:54 Uh, in certain scenarios we've seen a 2X lift in customer acquisition just from using, uh, that component that's a little bit more engaging. 12:03 Uh, you know, in general- We really do think that having a cell phone number at the center of identity is, uh, the best path forward in terms of customer acquisition. 12:13 Because to your point earlier, it's easy to go spin up an email if you really want 20% off and, you know, leave- Yeah... 12:18 and never kinda use that email again, whereas your cell phone number is something that you don't change often, and so you're gonna have, uh, more of a consistent thread, uh, with the audience that you're collecting through, through SMS. 12:31 And there's, you know, there is other tricks just generally in terms of doing like a full screen on, um, you know, mobile to, to, to do the capture that we, we see a lift in. Um, but, uh, yeah, I do think like 12:45 going back to something I said, y- you know, a little bit ago, just the more engaging and, and entertaining that experience is, the more likely the... It's kind of marketing 101. 12:54 The more likely that consumer is, um, is going to, um, be willing to, to play ball. Yeah. What about that post sign up, though? 13:03 So like once they've signed up, you know, you think from an email perspective, if they sign up for a newsletter- Mm-hmm... 13:07 traditionally, it's, "Hey, you know, here's what you can expect now that you've subscribed to us." Is that a relatively similar approach you suggest with SMS, or does that kinda get a little too lengthy? 13:17 I, I do think that there, uh, is a benefit in setting expectations, uh, early on when you're, you're getting that phone number from someone, especially probably in some ways even more so in SMS, because to your point, it is like a channel that, uh, people do not want... 13:33 You know, people wanna keep, uh, pristine in some ways. And so I think that it's important to say like, again, collecting those preferences, this is where two-way can be really interesting. 13:42 Like, "Hey, thank you so much for signing up for Guess brands," I'm just gonna... This is gonna be a commercial for Guess at the end of it. Um- [laughs]... 13:50 you know, w- uh, if you, uh, let us, if you wanna hear from us, like weekly, do press one, monthly, press two. 13:57 You know, so even like being able to have that kind of dialogue is something that you can't really do on email, and I think, uh, if you can like set those parameters up front, you're just, uh, you're going to, uh, have that fast track to creating more of that personalized experience, uh, with that customer. 14:15 And, um, you know, even though there's some investment upfront to do that, I think your performance down the road is gonna be much higher. Yeah. Now that we've, uh, given Guess plenty of airtime- [laughs]... 14:26 uh, which you're welcome. [laughs] Um, I loved the idea, actually, so it was a very good idea. 14:30 Do you have any others off the top of your head that you're like, "Oh, so and so, you know, they did this, and it was just a really cool idea that worked out well for them"? Um, I... 14:42 I mean, we have plenty of, of cool examples in our base. I think like, um, I think I... 14:47 a lot of the campaigns that I think are interesting too are not the like, "Hey, here, uh, give us your cell phone number, we'll give you 20% off," and just kind of that transactional, um, uh, campaign around discounts. 14:58 I love some of the educational campaigns I see our customers do. Uh, Supergoop is an example of this. 15:03 They do a bunch of education with their customers via text on, uh, on the benefits of sunscreen and how to think about skincare and how to think about aging. 15:13 Uh, and you know, they do that in a way that's, uh, again, they're, they're careful about how they segment that customer base, and they're gonna market that to people that they know are interested. 15:23 But I think like, again, earning the right to talk to these customers and not just be pushing product constantly, um, is an important, uh, is an important tactic to have in your, your tool set as a marketer. Yeah. 15:37 And I think it's something that, um, people sometimes discount because it's not like the like, you can't see that turn up in the spreadsheet the next day. 15:45 Uh, and I, but I do think there's something to be said for building a longer term relationship with these customers and, um, and not just always kind of hawking the, the newest product. Yeah. I agree. 15:57 We, we've definitely solidified that you don't wanna repeat your entire email marketing process- Yes... for SMS. However, do have another question about that. 16:07 How do you, or, or at least what is your suggestion in terms of how you get those two to work together? Let's do, take your traditional, your, your abandoned cart. 16:16 Do you really wanna email them and s- and shoot them a text message at the exact same time? Do you think it's better to stagger them? Like how do you keep it from... 16:25 You know, if you've got someone's email and you do have their phone number as well, how do you keep it from bombarding them and just being more of like a nice nudge? 16:33 I honestly don't know that there's a one size fits all answer for this, and I think that there are some brands where sending an email and then sending them a, an SMS 24 hours later is the right combination of things. 16:44 I think it can be pretty, um, brand specific, it can be specific to the price point, and we really- Okay... 16:50 try to work with our customers one-to-one to see like, all right, what are the patterns we're seeing in your data? 16:54 And then here, you know, let's figure out the right, um, combination of activities across SMS and email that are, that are gonna work for you. 17:01 Um, so you know, I don't, it's, uh, it's funny, like, uh, intuitively you'd say like, oh, bombarding them on both is actually gonna be, like you're gonna have a high opt-out rate or you're, you know, there, there's automatic places your head might go as a marketer, but that's, it's honest- interestingly enough, that's not always the case, and depending on the brand, that combo can actually work really well. 17:22 Uh, so, uh, unfortunately I don't have like a one size fits all answer for it. I do really think it's specific to what you're selling and, and what your customer ba- how your customer base generally responds. 17:32 Yeah, it's a very traditional marketing response. I feel you. Depends on the brand, depends on the product, depends on the customer. There's never one solid answer for anything. A/B test everything, see what happens. 17:43 Yes. Um, in terms of implementation stuff, so I know you've got a lot of experience obviously running marketing departments, scaling marketing departments. 17:52 From an SMS perspective, who do you typically have overseeing that entire approach? Are you tying it together with your retention and/or email marketing team? Are you having like a copywriter overseeing it? 18:03 Who's typically the one that's implementing those practices internally? Uh, for Attentive in terms of onboarding our own customer base? Sure, let's go with both. 18:13 Let's go with that, and then also what you usually suggest for your clients internally. Oh, okay. Got it. Yes. 18:20 Um, so, uh, you know, we have a client strategy team that really works closely with all of our customers to make sure that we're taking the best practices that we're learning across the 8,000 brands that we, we service, and applying them, you know, wherever it's, it's relevant. 18:35 Uh, and, um, you know, we wanna make sure that, uh, from a retention standpoint, that, um, they are thinking about, uh, you know, not just, um, 18:47 not just marketing the most relevant products, I think that is really critical in making sure that it's a personal experience, but again, also providing content that's gonna add value in different ways. 18:55 So, like the Supergoop example I mentioned, where they're offering not just, uh, "Hey, look, here's our newest product," but also, "Here's some tips about skincare in general." Yeah. Uh, or, um, 19:08 uh, I'm trying to think of another, uh, example on the, um... Oh, uh, loyalty too is another big, uh, component. So if you have, um, a crew of, uh, MVP customers, and, um, you know that they always wanna know about... 19:22 They wanna be on the, like, cutting edge or feel like they're in- Mm-hmm... 19:24 the insiders club of, like, what new things are coming out, you know, you're gonna segment them and make sure that they've got kind of that insider scoop. 19:31 Maybe they find out about something, you know, 48 hours early, and just feel like they're in part of this special club. 19:37 Um, you know, that is something that we've seen work in terms of, um, you know, building, you know, retention in your customer base, having people feel like, "Hey, this brand is really, um, gets me. 19:45 This is, like, one of the, you know, brands I want to keep in my phone forever, uh, because I feel like I really have this, this inside track that I've kind of earned over time." Yeah. 19:55 Yeah, those are, those are definitely some of the best ways that I've seen it work out, especially kind of like that VIP group of, like, hey, you're gonna get early access to certain things and stuff like that. 20:04 That is where I've seen SMS do fantastically. Um, question for you. Yes. Without saying their name, because we're not gonna give anyone any love on this show, 20:14 what's the biggest differentiator between Attentive and some of your competitors who we will not name? [laughs] Yeah, I mean, I think, like, we were, uh, we were pioneers in SMS marketing, and so we really do- Yeah... 20:25 truly believe that having, being mobile first is, um, critical to creating these personal experiences long term. That's why we, like, we really value having the cellphone number at the center of identity. 20:37 Um, I think second, conversational. 20:40 Uh, we believe that the best brand experiences don't feel like a, like a, a huge email blast where everyone's getting the same thing, but feel very personalized and curated, and you can have a two-way conversation, uh, with a brand. 20:54 Um, we are AI-powered. We have a massive focus right now on, um, making sure that our, uh, marketers that we serve are able to do more with less. I know it sounds trite, but we definitely... 21:06 It's not just about, uh, you know, saving time, but also creating better results by recognizing the patterns in our data, serving up better copy, serving up better imagery, uh, serving up better segmentation. 21:18 Like, we really wanna make sure that we're helping marketers make the best choices they can as quickly as they can, uh, and we've been, um, heavily investing in AI to do that. 21:28 And then the last I'd say is we're enterprise grade. We serve some of the largest retailers in the world, um, but we also can scale, we, we can scale up and down. 21:37 We ha- serve some of the most exciting entrepreneurial brands in the D2C space, all the way to the Neiman Marcuses of the world or Crocs or DICK'S Sporting Goods, um- Or Guess. 21:47 [laughs] And, you know, some of these huge brands trust us on some of their most critical days, and, uh, you know, we really pride ourselves on, uh, understanding customers of all sizes. Beautiful. 22:00 Sara, I really appreciate your time. I don't wanna take up too much more of your time. I know you're slammed. 22:04 Uh, I would love to give you an opportunity to let everyone know where they can find out more about you, and then obviously more about Attentive. Sure, absolutely. Please feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn. 22:12 My full name is Sara Varney Bright. I'm always, um, uh, happy to, to chat with people. Uh, you can find more about Attentive at attentive.com. 22:21 Uh, we'll be, uh, in New York we have a event called, uh, our Thread World Tour. We were named before Threads, I promise. Uh, and, um, that's in late September. You can find out more details on our website. 22:33 Uh, and otherwise we're at a lot of the events that many of you probably will be attending in the coming year, whether that's NRF or Shoptalk. So stop by our booth and say hi. We'd love to meet you. Perfect. 22:43 I will see you there. Great. Sara, thank you for your time. Everyone who tuned in, of course, thank you as well. 22:48 Please do the usual rate, review, subscribe, all that fun stuff on whichever podcast platform you prefer, or head over to the ecommshow.com to check out all of our previous episodes. 22:55 But as usual, thank you all for joining us, and we'll see you all next time. Have a good one. [upbeat music] Thank you for tuning in to The E-Comm Show. 23:04 Head over to ecommshow.com to subscribe on your favorite podcast platform or on the BlueTuskr YouTube channel. 23:12 The E-Comm Show is brought to you by BlueTuskr, a full service digital marketing company specifically for e-commerce sellers looking to accelerate their growth. Go to bluetuskr.com now for more information. 23:25 Make sure to tune in next week for another amazing episode of The E-Comm 23:45 Show. [upbeat music]